Стояюнин В.Я.. Мысли о наших экзаменах

MLICJIH

o uamux 3K3aMenax

He TOJibKO o;n;Ho ne;n;aromqecKoe 3HaqeHHe y Hae nMeeT B HaCTo.sn~ee epeMSI Bonpoc 06 3K3aMeHax; BIDKHee B HaIIIHX rna3ax ero co~HaJibHOe 3HaqeHHe, Ha KOTOpoe B 3TOH CTaTbe Mbl H XOTHM o6paTHTb oco6eHHOe BHHMaHHe. 3K3aMeHbl y Hae COCTaBIDllOT poKOBble BpaTa, qepe3 KOTOpbie HeH36e:>KHO npo:HTH KruKAOMY rpruKAaHHHY, tIT06b1 nonyqHTL Bee npaBa pyc-

cKoro rpruKAaHCTBa, T. e. npaea BCT)'IIHTbBO BCSIKYIO CJI)')K6yrocy;n;apCTBeffHYIO H o6~eCTBeffHYIO. ,[(JISI 3TOro OH ;D;OJI)f(eH npoHTH HeCKOJibKO cry-

neHeH, qro6bI OKOll'laTeJILHOBbIHTH Ha BOJlbHLIH 60)f(HH CBeT c ;n;HnnOMOM B pyKax H CaMoyeepeHHO HallaTL CBOe )f(HTeHCKOe CTJ>aHCTBHe, HHKor;n;a He

HMeSI }')KeHa;rt;06HOCTH HarJISl;n;HLIM o6pa30M ;n;oKa3bJBaTL KOM}'-JIH60CBOe o6pa30BaHHe, CBOH cne~aJibHbie n03HaHHSI, H)')KHLieB TOH HJIH ;n;pyroil

ccpepe ;n;esrrenbHOCTH. EM}'6b1eaeT uy)f(ffo TOJibKO 3acny)f(HTb 6naroeoneHHe HaqanbCTBa, H OH CMeJIO nepexo;n;HT HJIH nepeBO;D;HTCSI H3 O;n;HOH cne- ~aJibHOH ccpepbI B ;n;pyryio, ee3;n;e .smnucb no Bone Toro )f(e HaqanLCTBa H cnoco6HbIM, H 3HalO~M, H ;n;esrreJILHbIM, H ;rt;a)f(e noJie3HbIM, 3aCJI}7)f(l{Ba-

IO~ BCSIKHX MHJIOCTeil. Xopowo 3TO HJIH xy;n;o, noKa MLI HH cnoea. OcTaHOBHMCSI TOJlbKO Ha Tex nepBbIX CTYfieHSIX HCnbJTaTeJibHOH JieCTH~bl'

KOTOpb1e nepecrynHBweM}'HX ;n;aroT npaBa npuo6peTaTL quHbI B rocy;n;apCTBeHHoH CJI}')K6eH cne~anbHLie yqeHLie Il03HaHml B o6~eCTBeHHLIX BblC-

IDHX mKOJiax. CaMLIM MHOro3HaqHTeJibHbIM 3;n;ecb .smn.sreTc.sr TaK Ha3bIBaeMbIH rHMHa3uqecKHA 3K3aMeH, r;n;e IOHOWa np~eH ;n;oKa3bJBaTb CORM}' ne;n;aroroe H Hene;n;aroroB, mmr;n;a ;rt;a)f(e npu TOp)f(eCTBeHHoH o6CTaHOBKe, qTO OH ycnen npuo6peCTH TY ;D;OJIIO no3HaHHH, KOTopa.sr npH3HaHa BJiaCTSIMH Heo6xo;n;HMoro ;n;n.sr pyccKoro o6pa3oBaHHoro 'lenoBeKaBoo6~e H ;rt;JISI pycKoro qmfOBHHKa B oco6eHHOCTH. IlOHSITHO, qTo 3TOT 3K3aMeH ;n;enaeTCSI BeCbMa Ba:>KHLIM eonpocOM )f(H3HH ;D;JISI Ka:xc;n;oro ceMeHCTBa }')KeHe B CMLI-

cne ne;n;aromqeCKOM, a B CMbICJie rpruKAaHCKOM, TaK KaK OH Ka:>IC;n;OM}' IOHOWe OTKpLmaeT ;n;opory Ha pa3Hble nonpu~a. 3;n;ecb He3aBHCHMO OT

o6pa30B3HIDI pa3pemaeTCSI Bonpoc 0 TOM, Ky;n;a OH MO)f(eT HanpaBHTb CBOH

CHJibl H KaKyIO Il0Jlb3Y npHHOCHTL ce6e'ceMeHCTBY'o6~eCTBY H rocy;n;apCTBy. I10HS1TH0, qro H ;n;m1 caMoro o6~ecrea H rocy;n;apcrea eonpoc 3TOT

;n;enaeTCSI BeCbMa B~blM BOnpOCOM rpa:xc;n;aHCKHM'TaK KaK OHH nOCTOSIHHO HY:>IC;n;alOTCSI B xopowHX CHJiax, B ;n;apoBHTLIX JIIO;D;SIX, B pa3BHTbIX )1M3X H TaK KaK OHH MHOro Tepn.srT'eCJIH XOTb '13CTbH3 3THX CHJI npona;n;aeT no

B. }I. CTOIOHHH. Mb1C11H o nawHx 3K3aMeHax

KaKHM-JIH60 IIpH11HHaM, 3a,qep)KaBIIIHM HX pa3BHTHe HJIH He ,qaBIIIHM HM ceo6o,qHO HarrpaBHTbCSI 3aKOHHbIMH nyTSIMH; c ,qpyrou CTOpOHbl, OHH MHOro TepnSIT' eCJIH Ha 3TH IlYTH CKOpee H Jlerqe MOryT npo6HBaTbCSI nocpe,q- CTBeHHOCTb, 6e3,qapHOCTb, oryneJIOCTb , ,qep30CTb H HarJIOCTb, ycneB HacKopo y,qosJ1eTeopHTh H3BeCTHhIM 11HHOBHo-ne,qarorH'JecKHMTPe6oea- HHSIM. c TaKHMH eHJlaMH He,qaneKO y~eT o6iqeCTBeHHaSI H rocy,qapCTBeHHaSI )KH3Hh. Mhl He ,qyMaeM, 11To HY)KHO npHBOAHTh MHoro ,qoKa3aTeJibCTB B no,qTeep)K)l;eHHe errpaee,qJ1HsoeTH Ha111eu MbienH. CBSl3h Ha111Hx 3K3aMeHOB e o6iqero )KH3Hbl0 He MO)KeT He 3aMeTHTb Ka)K)l;blH' Aa)Ke HHeKOJlbKO He HHTepeeyroiqHHeSI HaIIIHMH ne,qarorffl·IeeKHMH BOnpoeaMH. 0Tero,qa 011eHb eCTeCTBeHHO Ka)K)l;OMY 3aAyMaTbeSI, AOCTHralOT JIH HaUJH 3K3aMeHbl TOH Ba)KHOH QeJIH' KaKaSI HM noeTaBJISleTCSI' sepHO JIH OHH MOryT OQeHHBaTb CHJlbl H Il03HaHHSI MOJIOAbIX JIIOAeH.

3K3aMeH - JIOTepeSI, BOT e~eHHe, KOTOpoe y)Ke ,qaBHO CJibIIIIHTeSI B HaIIIeM o6iqeCTBe H KOTopoe BbIKa3hIBaeT IlOJIHOe He,qoeepHe KO Bee:R CHCTeMe cyiqeCTByroiqHx 3K3aMeHos. Ey,qeM JIH MhI onpoeepraTb 3TO cy)K-

,qeHHe? IlpoTHB Hae BbICTaBHJIH 6bJ CTOJibKO Heonposep)KHMbIX <t>aicTOBl 11To HaM npHIIIJIOeb 6b1 3aMon11aTb H YAaJIHTbCSI e esoe:R He~a11HOK nonbIT-

KOH. 3,qecb MhI ycTPaHS1eM sonpoe o 3J1oynoTPe6nemmx BJlaCTH, o 1o1aMepeHHbIX Hecrrpase,qJIHBOeTSIX, 0 npoAa)Ke AHnJIOMOB H op.''lJTO,rOBOpSIT' Hepe,qKo cnyqaJ1oeb a ,qo6poe CTapoe speMSI, H npe,qnonaraeM, 11To see 3TO B Harne speMSI He TO 11TO HeB03MO)KHO, a ... npoCTO He 6bJBaeT. IlocnymaeM cnepsa, qTo rosopSIT caMH 3K3aMeffYIOI.QHeesr nocne Ka)K)l;oro 3K3aMeHa. 0AHH e BOCToproM paeeKa3bIBaeT''lJTOH3 CTa 6HJieTOB OH 3HaJI xopomo TOJibKO AeCSITb H ,qsa H3 HHX IlOilaJIHCb eMY; OH 60HKO OTBeTHJI H OOJIY11HJI BbiemH:ff 6aJIJI. Ji:pyro:R'HanpOTHB'o6"bSIBJISleT 11YTb He co CJle3aMH''lJTOOH He ycneJI rrpoeMOTPeTb TOJlbKO IlSITH 6HJleTOB H'KaK Hap011HO'OAHH H3 HHX nonaneS1 eMY, OH c6HJieS1 H nony11Hn HeyAOBJ1eTBOpHTeJ1bHhIH 6ann. TpeTHH eoexHiqaeTeSI TeM e11aCTbeM''lJTOeMY IIpHIIIJIOeb OTBe'lJaTbH3 nocne,qHHX' KOr,qa 3K3aMeHaTOpbl Kpafme YTOMHJIHeb, enpaIIIHBaJIH CJierKa, KOe-11TO, HHa11e OH HenpeMeHHO n p 0 B a JI H JI e SI 6 bl. lleTBepTblH npoKJIHHaeT CBOIO po60CTb, KOTopyro IIpHHSIJIH 3a He3HaHHe H c e,qHHHQelO YAaJIHJIH ero OT 3eJ1eHoro CTOJia. lliTbIH ysepS1eT, 11To OH xopomo 3HaJI eecb npeAMeT, HO Heenan H011b, CHASI 3a npHrOTOBJieHHeM, B rOJIOBe ero Bee ·CMelllaJIOCb, OH enyTaJieSI B eBOHX OTBeTax, H pOKOBOe He 3 Hae Te pemHJIO ero y11aCTb. illeCTOH 06'bS1eHS1eTnpH11HHY CBOero Hec11aCTHS1 IIpHAHp11HBOCTblO 3K3aMeHaTopa, yKa3bIBasr ua Apyrmc, KOTOpb1e 3HaJOT MeHLme H xyx<e ero H IlOJIYlJHJIH YAOBJieTBOpHTeJibHYIO OTMeTKY B AByx marax OT Hero Ha 3K3aMeHe y ,qpyroro, He CTOJlb IlPHAHP11HBOro. MbI MOrJIH 6bI HacqHTaTh MHOrO DOA06HblX paeeKa30B'H3 KOTOpbIX JIOrHqeeKH BblBOAHTeSI OAHO 3aKJII011eHHe: 3K3aMeH - noTepesr. Ha HeM nosKOCTh, cMeJIOCTh, po6oCTL, rrpoeTaSI cnyqaHHOCTb qaCTO SIBJISllOTeSI CHJlbHee H Ba)Kffee Il03HaHHH. Ha HeM HHorna AapOBHTbIH H 3HalOiqHH IOHOIIIa OKa3bIBaeTeSI HeCOCTOSITeJibHblM' a nosepXHOCTHbIH, MaJIO pa3BHTblH HJIH Aep3KHH BblXOAHT e TOp)KeCTBOM. Bee 3TO BhIBOAbI, c,qeJ1aHHh1e He HaMH. HaM, KOHe11Ho, MOryT 3aMeTHTb: HeJlb3SI BepHTb BCeMy' qTO paccKa3bIBaeT IOHOIIIa B onpas,qaHHe eeoe:R

B. .sl. CTOIOHHH

HeyAa'lHHJIH Aaxe H~ xBaCTJIHBOCTH. Ho y Hae eeTh B03MO)KHOCTh nposepHTh paccKa3hI eaMOIO AeHeTBHTeJihHOCThlO. IlocTaBHM sonpoe TaKuM o6pa30M: npH TOH o6eTaHOBKe, npH scex Tex ycnosm1X H cnoeo6ax enpaWHBaHIDI, KaKHe 06hIKHOBCHHO eyIQeCTBylOT y Hae Ha 3K3aMeHax ' \tOXeT JIH CJiyqHTbe.SI, ':IT06MOJIOAOH 'leJIOBeK,OeHOBaTeJibHO nparOTOBJieHHblH H pa3BHTbIH, IlOJIY'lHJIHa 3K3aMeHe HeyAOBJieTBOpHTeJihHYIO OTMeTKY H, Ha06opoT'e KpaAHe nosepXHOeTHbIMH Il03HaHHSIMH OKa3aJieSI 6bl .a;oeTOHHhlM noJiyqHTb BO:>fCAeJieHHblH aTTeCTaT?

06paTHM npe:>KAe BHHMaHHe Ha 3K3aMeHyIOLqHXe.SI H Ha 3K3aMeHaTopoB. KTo eKOJibKO-HH6yAh Ha6JIIOAaJI HaA MOJIOAhIMH JIIOAbMH, TOT xopowo 3HaeT. e KaKHM CTpaxOM .SIBJI.SleTe.SI Ha 3K3aMeH eaMoe orpOMHOe 60JihWHHCTBO H3 HHX: Ha Aee.SITh 'leJIOBeKHaliAeTe.SI pa3Be OAHa HaTypa, KOTOpa.SI MOXeT OBJiaAeTb eo6010 H Hapy)KHO He IlOKa3aTb 3TOro crpaxa, H Ha ABaA-

~aTb Il.SITh Bp~ JIH HaffAeTeSI OAHa eMeJia.SI Harypa, KOTOpa.SI AeHeTBHTeJibHO He ':IYBCTBOBaJia6bl HHKaKoro crpaxa. 3TO TSDKeJioe qyseTBO OBJiaAesaeT He TOJlbKO TeMH, KTO e03HaeT'':ITOHe see qaeTH nporpaMMbl npHrOTOBJICHbl HM OAHHaKOBO oeHOBaTeJILHQ; HO Aaxe H Te, KOTOpbie y6exAeHbl B eBOHX Il03HaHH.SIX, H OHH DOMaIOTe.SI HeBOJlhHOMY eTPaxy. A eKOJlhKO Me:>KAy HHMH naliAeTe.SI no npHpoAe po6KHX HJIH THXHX, HeHaxOA'lHBhlXHJIH e He6bICTphIM eoo6paxeHHeM, KOTOpLie H B o6LIKHOBeHHOM pa3rOBOpe e 'IY:>KHMH JllOAbMH KOncpy3.S1Te.s1, Tep.SllOTe.SI, Mewa10Te.S1, TaK 'lTO HHOrAa O'leHhuernynhie MOJIOAhle JIIOAH Mory'T JJerKO IlOKa3aTbe.SI O'leHhHeAaJieKHMH. ITOH.SITHO, KaKoe BDe'laTJieHHeHa HHX AOJI)Kffa npOH3BOAHTh y)Ke OAHa MhlCJib 06 3K3aMene, rAe BHHMaHHe MHOI11X JI~ 6yAeT eoepeAOTO'leHO ua OAHOM - Ha ero OTBeTax. K yeHJieHHIO eTPaxa eJiy)KHT eIQe H neAosep- 'lHBOCThHeKOTOpbIX MOJIOAhIX JIIOAeH K caMHM ce6e, Ka'leeTBO,KOTOpoe HHKaK ueJib3.SI DOCTaBHTh B nopoK IOHOWe'ueysepeHHOeTh B eBOHX eHJiax HJIH HeKoropoe caMOJII06He, KOTOpoe B MhlCJISIX npeyBeJIH'lHBaeTeTLIA, eCJIH CJiyqHTC.SI ueyAa'laB OTBeTax; naKOHeQ, 6eCCOHHhie HO'lH,KOTOpLie npoBOA.SfT nepeA 3K3aMeHaMH 06LIKHOBCHHO Jl}"IWHe yqenHKH H3 xeJiaHHSI 3apa3 Bee DOBTOpHTh H npHBeCTH ce6e Ha naM.SITb'npH 3TOM pacena6JieHHe

HepBOB, KpaAHee YTOMJieHHe CHJI - BOT c KaKHMH HCBhirOAHhIMH YCJIOBH-

.SIMH .S1BJI.S1eTcJ1 6oJibWHHCTBO MOJIOALIX JIIOAeH Ha 3K3aM~HbI. H3 3Toro ':IHCJiaMhl He HeKJIIO'laeM.r.axe mMHa3HCTOB'KOTOphle 3HalOT''lTO6YAYT 3K3aMeHOBaTbC.SI y 3HaKOMhIX npenoAaBaTeJieH, nepeA 3HaKOMhlM Ha'laJih-

CTBOM, B 3HaKOMOH 3aJie, Aaxe H OHH HaxOA.SfTe.SI B KpaHHe HeenOKOHHOM H so36y~eHHOM COCTm1mrn; KaK }Ke AOJI}l{HO 6HTLCSI cepAQe y noCTopoHHHX

MOJIOAhIX JIIOACH, KOTOpbIM He3HaKOMLI Bee JIHQa, BC.SI o6CTaHOBKa, oco6eHHO npH Tex KpalfHe HeonpeAeJieHHhlX H o6WHpHbIX nporpaMMax, KaKHe y Hae cyIQeCTBYIOT AJig 3K3aMeHoB.

BoT TYT-TO 6hl H CJICAOBaJIO O)KHJJ;aTh, 'lTOOHH 6YAYT BCTpe'leHhIHaCToSllQHMH neAaroraMH'KOTOphie AOJI)Kffhl 6h1Tb xopowo 3HaKOMbl c IOHOWeCKOIO npHpoAOIO'KOTOpbIC yMelOT npOHHKffYTb B MOJIOA)'IOAYwy'o60APHTh ee, ycnoKOHTL, yCTpaHHTb Bee, 'lTOMO}l{eT CM)'THTLH npHBeCTH B 3aMewaTeJILCTBO po6Koro MOJIOAOfO 'lCJIOBeKa,DOMO'lheM)'CBOOOAHO BhIKa3aTb CBOH ACHCTBHTeJILHhie no3naHID1, ue3aMeTno BLI3LIBaTL c ero eToponLI

B. 51. CTOK>HHH . Mb1cmt o Haurnx 3K :.rnMcHax

TaKHe OTBeTbl, no KOTOpbIM 6bl MO>KHO 6bIJIO CYAHTb 0 ero YMCTBeHHOM

pa3BHTHH. Ecrb nH y Hae TaKHe neAarom? Mo)KeT 6bITL, H ecr1>, HO 3aTo eCTL H Apyme, KOTOpbie, B cy~HOCTH, He 6onee KaK -'IHHOBHHKH,C03A3B-

WHe ce6e COBCeM oco6yro, tfHHOBHHtfblO neAaromJO. 0 Hen KOfA3-HH6YAL

Mbl noroaopHM B noAp06HOCTH'TaK KaK OHa y Hae AenaeTC$1 rocnOACTBY- JO~eJO. 3AeCb )Ke nOCMOTPHM, KaK y Hae OtfeHL tfaCTO npoH3BOAJITC$1 3K3a-

MeHLI. Tpe6yeTC.SI n p H c y T c T B H e HeCKOJibKHX neAaroroa'KOTOpbie H

AOJI>KHbl coo6~a OQeHHBaTb n03H8HH$1 H onpeAeJIHb CTeneHb 3peJIOCTH 3K3aMeHyJO~eroc.sr. IleAarorH'leCKHeCOBeTbl COCT0$1T H3 cnel.UfMHCTOB no

BceM yqe6HblM npeAMeTaM rHMHa3H'leCKoroJCYPC3; nOH$1THO'tfTO K3)1{AblH MO)KeT TOtfHO H cnpaBeAJIHBO OQeHHB8Tb TOJibKO n03HaHIUI no CBOeM}' npeAMery H He MO)KeT 6b1Tb 3K3aMeHaTOpoM no TOM}'npeAMery'KOTOpbIH OH neAaromt1ecKH He pa3pa6aTbIBan. HeT cnopy, t1To OHH KOrAa-ro caMH 06yt1anHcL ace 3THM npeAMeTaM, Aa)Ke cnywanH HeK0Top1>1e H3 HHX B YHH- aepcHTeTe, HO HeT cnopy, tfTO nonOBHHa H3 acero 3TOro HMH }')Ke3a6bJTa, tfTO Bee HOBOe, OTKpbITOe HJIH HCCJieAOBaHHOe HayKOIO nocne HX 06y1 1.:HJU1, H3BeCTHo HM 6onee no cnyxaM; a Me)l{Ay reM, 'IT0661>1TL CYAheJO HJIH OQeH-

~KoM APYroro, t1To61>1 pewaTh cyA1>6y ero, H}')KHOcaMOMY anonHe ana- neTL npeAMeToM, a He .S1BJI.S1TLC.S1 a Kat1ecrae CYALH c o6pLIBKaMH nony3a6L1TbIX no3HaHHH; H)'>KHO YMeTh npeAnaraTL aonpochI, t1T061>1 BbI3bIB3Tb

T3KHe OTBeTbl, no KOTOpbIM MO>KHO 61>1 6bIJIO y6e)l{AaTLC$1 He B OAHOH CHJie naM.SITH OTBe'l:aJO~ero, HO 6onee Bero YMCTBeHHOM pa3BHTHH H B WHpOTe

ero IlOH.SITHH; H)'>KHO3HaTb, tfTO cnpawHBaTb, a He 3aKHAbIB8Tb cnyqa:H- HblMH BOnpocaMH'KaKHe npHAYT ea YM H3 crapHHHOro Kypca HJIH npocMOTPeHHOro HaKaH)'Heyqe6HHKa. IloH.SITHO, t1To B 3TOM cnyqae He Ka)l{AbIH MO)KeT 6bITb 3K3aMeHaTOpOM, Aa>Ke eCJIH 6bI OH yqeHbIM o6pa30M 6bIJI 3HaKOM c npeAMeTOM; npH 3TOM ueo6XOAHMO H neAarorH'leCKHBJiaAeTb HM. HTaK, t1To61>1 3K3aMeH 6bm npOH3BeAeH cnpaBeAJIHBO, T. e. t1T06b1 AaHa 6blna caM8$1 aepH8$1 oQenKa BceMY, tfTO AOJI>KHO 6b1Tb OQeneuo Ha 3K3aMeue, BbI6HpaJOTC.SI CYAbH a t1Hcne uecKOJibKHX HJIH Aa)Ke MHOrHX JIHQ; a

Me~y TeM 60JibWa.SI tfaCTb H3 HHX AMeKO He MOfYT 6hITb HaCTOmIUIMH CYAb.SIMH, tfTO OHH xopowo 3HaJOT H caMH. CnyqaeTC.sr, tfTO B QenoM co6paHHH cyAeH TOJibKO OAHO JIHQO MO)KeT Ha3BaTbC.SI cneQHanbHbIM no AaHHOM}' npeAMery, KaK, HanpHMep, B HeKOTOpbIX rHMHa3WIX TOJILKO no OAHOM}' npenoAaBaTemo HCTOpHH, HJIH reorpacf>HH, HJIH cf>H3HKH. K0Het1Ho, 3TH H OBJiaAeBaJOT 3K3aMeHOM, cnpawHBa.SI TO, tfTO IlOABepH)'JIOCbHa BblH)'TOM 6HJieTe, HJIH TO, tfTO HM oco6eHHO HpaBHTC.SI, BbIC3)KM, no neAarorH'leCKOMY Bbipa)KeHHJO, Ha CBOHX KOHLKax, npffAaBa.SI oco6oe 3HatfeHHe IlOAp06HOCT.SIM, KOTOpbie Ha 3K3aMeHe He AOJI>KHbl 6bJ HMeTb HHKaKoro 3HatfeHIUI, TPe6y.sr 3HaHH.SI'TaKHX Menot1e:H, KOTOpbie 6epyTC.SI JIHWb naM.SITblO H noTOM

6bJCTp0 3a6bIBaJOTC.SI, H He KaCa.SICb Cyn(eCTBeHHoro, tfTO MO)KeT CBffAeTeJibCTBOBaTb 0 npot1HblX n03HaHIUIX 3K3aMeHyJO~erOC.SI. HHbie HCnbITbIBaJOT

IOHOwy, KaK MawHHy: 6HJieT eCTb KJIJOtf, KOTOpbIM OHa 38BOAHTC.SI; eCJIH,

3aBeAeHH8$1, OHa He nomna H3BCCTllbIM XOAOM, TO OHa OKa3bl83CTC.SI HerOAHOJO; eCJIH )Ke OHa npoTPe~ana, HHI1(e He 38IIHYBWHCb, TO HCnbITYIO~ OCTaeTCSI AOBOJieH. y HHOro npHCYTCTBYJO~ero HecneQHanHCTa, MO)KCT

B. .SI. CTOIOHHH

6bITb, H .sIBHTCg COMHeHHe, nOHHMaeT JIH OTBetJalOI..QHH ace TO, tJTO TaK 6blC'fPOBb16pacb1aaeT H3 caoeH. ronoBbI, HO npoaepHTb ero OH He pewaeT-

cg, nOTOMY tJTO caM 3a6b1JI noAp06HoCTH; wenHeT COCeAy - TOT YJibI6HeTcg: He npepbIBaif.Te, AeCKaTb, 6naro OTBe'lfaeT,He 3aAep:>K.HaaeT. 11 BOT n p H c y T c T B y IO I..Q H e H cnywalOI..QHe HCilbITaHHe no eAHHOH BOJie HatiaJibCTBa CTaBgT OTMeTKH no B n e q a T JI e H H IO 6onee Ha lIYBCTBO cnyxa. Bnpo'lfeM,KTO nOA06pocoaecTHee, TOTH He CTOHT 3a CBOH OTMeTirn npH OKOH'lfaTeJibHOM06D.J;eM COBeI..QaHHH; OH ycrynaeT rnaBHOMY 3K3aMeHaTopy, KOTOpOMY AOBepgeT KaK cneQHaJIHCTY B CBOeM AeJie, paBHO KaK H TOT, B CBOIO oqepeAh, ycTynaeT eMy no ero npeAMeTy. Ho 6bIBalOT H c TaKHMH CHJibHbIMH anetJaTJieHHgMH, lJTO 6e3 cnopa He OTCTynalOT OT CBOHX OTMeTOK: eCJIH MOJIOAOH qeJIOBeK OTBetJan He6bIC'fPOHJIH HeCKOJibKO TgHyJI

CBOH OTBeTbl, 3aAYMbIBancg HaA aonpocaMH, TO xoTg 6bI OTBelJaJI H OCHOBaTeJibHO, HO yxo npHCYTCTBYIOI..Qero He Hacna~aJIOCb 6bICTpOTOIO H nnaa-

HOCTblO H aneqaTJieHHe y Hero OCTaJIOCb He COBCeM 6naronpHgTHOe: CYAbg 'rpe6yeT'tJT06bI H ero OTMeTKY BBeJIH B 061..QHH CtJeT.

HHoMy 3K3aMeHaTopy nio6o 6L1aaeT npocnbITb C'rpaWHhIM;OH HaXOAHT ce6e oco6euHoe YAOBOJibCTBHe npeAnaraTb TPYAHhie aonpocb1, TPeGoaaTb CKOpbIX OTBeTOB, npHBOAHTb B HeAOYMeHHe pa3Hb1MH Heo~aHHOCTgMH,

CMyI..QaTb, c6HBaTb H OKaHtJHBaTb aeyAOBJieTBOpHTeJibHOH OTMeTKOH. l1Hble HAYT eI..Qe AaJiee: HaA 6eAHbIM CMyI..QeHHbIM IOHOweH. OHH ynpa)KJUllOT

CBOe OC'fPOYMHe, rJiyMgTcg HaA ero OWH6KaMH, Harno nOACMeHBalOTcg HaA ero He3HaHHeM, ~O)KeT 6bITb, Aa)Ke MHHMbIM, H 3THM caMblM OKOH1.Ja-

TeJibHO c6uaaioT ero u cTaagT B TynuK, TOrAa KaK npu ApyroM cnoco6e cnpawHBaTb po6KHH IOHOWa MOr 6LI OTBeTHTb Ha ace BOilpOCbl H AOKa3aTb CBOH OCHOBaTeJibHbie n03HaHug. l1HOrAa cnyqaeTcg, lJTO 3K3aMeHaTop H npucyTCTBYIOI..QHe, )KeJiag OKOHlJHTb 3K3aMeH B OAHH AeHb HJIH npuHy~eH­

Hbie K TOMY Heo6xOAHMOCThlO, TgHYT ero c YTPa tIYTh ue AO nonyuotJu. Mo)Kffo O)KffAaTb, a KaKOM cocToguuu, u AyxOBHOM u cpu3HY:eCKOM, IlOAXOAgT K CTOJIY 3K3aMeHyIOI..QHecg aeqepoM: npoBeAg nocJieAHIOIO HOlJb,

MO)KeT 6hITh, 6e3 cHa, aech AeHb a TOMHTeJihHOM O)KffAaHHH , yToMJieHHbie ~OJirHM CHACHHeM Ha OAHOM MeCTe' OHH He MoryT coo6pa3HTb caMbIX

nycThIX aonpocoa, a Ha 6uneTax nepeA ux rna3aMH aonpocLI otJeHh cepbe3Hhle; OHH OWH6aIOTcg, AalOT TaKHe OTBeTbl , 3a KOTOpbie TOTlJaC )Ke caMH KpacHeioT; caMH CYAhH OT ycTanocTH eABa roaopgT H ace )Ke npoAOJI)KalOT OQeHHBaTb OTBeTLI MOJIOAhIX JIIOAe:H H pewaTb CYAh6y HX. HcnLITaHHe o6paI.QaeTcg B IlblTKY'H HHKTO He AYMaeT OTKa3aTbcg OT TaKOH pOJIH,

Ka~blH CCbIJiagcb ua AOJir H o6g3aHHOCTH, npeAilHCaHHble HalJaJibCTBOM. Ehrna10T npHMepb1 , tJTO caMu ucnhITaTenu nocne HeCKOJibKHX qacoa HalJHHaIOT OWH6aTbCg B BbltIHCJieHugx, npH noaepKe 3aAaq 3K3-aMeHYIOJ.l\HXCg 060.sIBJig10T HeaepHbIMH aepHLie peweaug H, He 3aTPYAH.SfjJCb, CTaBJIT HeyAOBJICTBOpHTCJibHbie 6aJIJibl.

0wH60lJHO nonaralOT HCKOTOpble' 6yATO no ABYM-TJ>CM OTBeTaM co CTOpOHbl 3K3aMeHyIOI..Qerocg MO)KHO yoeAHTbCg, 3HaeT HJIH He 3HaeT OH

BCCb rrpeAMeT. 3K3aMeHyg CBOHX co6cTBeHHbIX ytJeHHKOB, 3K3aMeHaTop AeHCTBHTeJibHO MO)KeT AOXOAHTb AO TaKoro y6e~eHug; HO H TYT MaJIO-

B. ~. CTOIOHHH . MbICJIH o nawHX 3K3aMenax

OIIbITHbIH HJIH HeTeprreJIHBbIH Hepe)J;KO OIJIH6aeTCSI: CMy~eHHe yqeHHKa OH npHHHMaeT 3a He3HaHHe; eCJIH B KJiacce ytJeHHK OTJIHlJaJICSI 60HKOCTblO, a Ha 3K3aMeHe BbIKa3hIBaeT po60CTb H He npe:>KHIOIO 6bICTPYIO coo6pa3HTeJibHOCTb, TO 3TO npHHHMaeTCSI TaIOKe B HeBbirO)J;HOM CMbICJie )J;JISI IOHOWH; rOBOpSIT'lJTO OH DO)J;)J;aJICSI JieHH'He 3aHSIJICSI KaK CJie)J;yeT npHrOTOBJie-

HHeM K 3K3aMeHy' CJIHIJIKOM DOHa)J;eSIJICSI Ha ce6SI; a MOJIO)J;OH qeJIOBeK, MO:>Ke·T 6b1Tb, He cnan ~eJibie HOlJH 3a KHHraMH H TeTPaASIMH, T~aTeJibHO

DOBTOPHJI Bech Kypc, HO TOJlbKO He II03a60THJ1CSI DO)J;KpeIIHTb ce6SI CHOM H 3a 3TO BbIHOCHT H3 3K3aMeHa HeBbirO)J;HOe 0 ce6e MHeHHe CBOHX cy]J;eH. llT06bI C)J;eJiaTb Bepeyio o~eHKY 003HaHHSIM H pa3BHTHIO DOCTOpOHHero MOJIO)J;Oro qeJIOBeKa, SIBHBIIIerocSI Ha 3K3aMeH, )J;aJieKO He)J;OCTaTOlJHO )J;ByxTPeX BOnpocoB HJIH )J;a:>Ke 60HKHX Ha HHX OTBeTOB: B 3TOM CJiyqae CKOporoBOpKa HJIH H3BeCTHaSI 6bICTpOTa HHKaK He MOryT CJIY:>KHTb )J;OKa3aTeJib-

CTBOM OCHOBaTeJihHOro 3HaKOMCTBa c npe)J;MeTOM HJIH YMCTBeHHoro pa3BHTHSI. llaCTO CJiyqaeTCSI, lJTO OTBetJalO~HH, 00-BH,I(HMOMY'BSIJIO H 3aIIHHa-

SICb, 3HaeT B )J;eHCTBHTeJibHOCTH npe)J;MeT ropa3)1;0 OCHOBaTeJibHee Toro ,

KOTOpbIH 60HKO BbI6paCbIBaeT OTBeTbl. Boo6~e TOpOIIJIHBOCTb 3K3aMeHaTOpOB npHHOCHT caMbIH c~eCTBeHHbIH Bpe)J; )J;eny, H, ecJIH c O)J;HOH cropoHbl, HeKOTOpbIM He3aCJiy:>KeHHO IIOMOraeT B xopomelf arrecra~, 3aTO

APYrHX, 6onee JJ:OCTOHHbIX, JIHIJiaeT B03MO:>KHOCTH JJ:OCTaTOtJHO y6e)J;HTb B

CBOHX 003HaHHSIX. 3K3aMeHaTOpbl 6onee BCero )J;OJl:>KHbl 3a60THTbCSI 0 TOM, lJT06bI 3K3aMeffYIO~HHCSI He CMOTPeJI Ha ce6SI, KaK Ha HX :>KepTBY'lJT06bI

QH OTOIJieJI OT HHX c DOJIHbIM y6e)K)J;eHHeM, lJTO c HHM He C)J;eJiaHO HHtJero HecnpaBe)J;JIHBoro H He3aKOHHoro. Heo6xo)J;HMO scer)J;a noMHHTb, tJTO aTOT MOMeHT'MO:>KeT 6bITb, caMblH sa:>KiibIH B :>KH3HH MOJIO)J;Oro qeJIOBeKa, lJTO npH 3TOM BCSIKaSI HeJIOBKOCTb co CTOpOHbl 3K3aMeHaTopa, BCSIKaSI ero OTMeTKa, KOTOpaSI MO:>KeT DOKa3aTbCSI HecnpaBe)J;JIHBOIO, CHJibHO OO)J;eHCTByeT Ha B036y)K)J;eHHbIH )J;yx IOHOIIIH H nerKO MO:>KeT IIOBeCTH K 03JI06JieHHIO, OT KOTOporo Mbl )J;OJI:>KHbl 6epetib MOJIO)J;blX JIIO)J;eH. 3)1;eCb 60JiblllaSI tJaCTb H3 HHX ]J;eJiaeT nepBbIH Illar B HaCTosnu;y10, )J;eHCTBHTeJibHYIO :>KH3Hb, SIBJISISICb Ha cyA He3HaKOMbIX, tJY:>KHX JIIO)J;eH:; 3)1;ecb HM snepBbie npHXOJJ:HTCSI y6e)J;HTbCSI, tJTO TOJibKO co6crseHHbIM TPYAOM 3aHHMaeTCSI H3BeCTHoe npotIHOe rrono:>KeHHe B :>KHJHH, tJTO B03Harpa)K)J;eHHe Ja TPYA, KaK ero CJieACTBHe, BhITeKaeT H3 Hero caMoro. HeMHome AYMalOT, tJTO 3K3aMeHbI HMelOT BJlHSIHHe Ha HpaBCTBeHffYIO cropoHy HeKOTOpbIX MOJIO)J;bIX JIIO)J;elf; lJTO OTCIO)J;a OHH BbIHOCSIT H3BeeTHbie HpaBCTBeHHLie y6e)K)J;eHHSI'.KOTOpbie noTOM HecKopo ocTaBJISIIOTCSI. TaK ffY:>KHO :>Ke nocrapaTLCSI ycTPaHHTL Bee TO, lJTO MO:>KeT c rrepsoro :>Ke mara HaBeCTH MOJIO)J;Oro qeJIOBeKa Ha MbICJIL, 6y)J;TO B :>KH3HH CaMOe Ba:>KHoe - .- CJiyqaHHOCTL, KOTOpaSI )J;OCTaBJISleT see JIIOJJ:SIM, tJTO Ha Hee, a He Ha TPYA, H CJie]J;yeT Ha)J;eSITLeSI, JJ:YMaSI o 6yAy~eM.

llT06LI DOKOHlJHTL Beeb 3K3aMeH B ]J;aHHLIH cpoK, Hepe)J;KO 3K3aMeHaTOpLI H CYJJ:bH pa3)1;eJISllOTCSI Ha OT)J;eJibHLie KOMHCCHH H B O)J;HO H TO :>Ke

speMSI B pa3HbIX yrnax 3a.JILI 3aHHMa10TeS1 HenbITaHHeM. CyAL6a MOJIOJJ:bIX JIIO)J;eH OT)J;aeTcSI B pyKH OJJ:HOro aKJaMeHaTopa-crre~anHCTa. OH, MO:>KeT

6bITb, H OtJeHb )J;06poeoBeCTHbIH qeJIOBeK, MO:>KeT 6LITL, )J;a:>Ke H xopOIIIHH ne)J;aror, HO Bee :>Ke OH MO:>KeT OIIIH6aTbeSI; a eeJIH OH He eosceM )J;06poeo-

B. 51 . CTOtOHHH

BeCTHhlH, eCJIH OH npHCTpaCTHbIH, BCllbIJibqHBbIH, ysneKalO~HCJI, AeJiaIOI.QHH nocnewHLie 3aKJ110'leHW1H np. H np. -KTO MO)KeT 3a Hero pyqancJ1? AccHCTeHT ero noqTH He npHHHMaeT yqaCTHS1 B ero Aene no MaJIOMY 3HaKOMCTBY c npeAMeTOM, TaK KaK OH Cilel.\HaJibHO 3aHHMaeTCJI HCTOpHeif,. a 3K3aMeH ffAeT H3 cpH3HKH HJIH KOCMorpacpHH; npoqHe 3aHJITLI a APYrHX KOMHCCWIX H y)Ke COBeeM HHqero He CJibIWaT; H OCTaeTCJI pelllHTeJibHOIO TOJibKO OAHa OTMeTKa. ECJIH OHa OKa)KeTCJI HeyAOBJieTBOpHTeJibHOH, TO Aeno MOJIOAoro 'le!IOBeKanpoHrpaHo: HO He MO)KeT nonpaBHTb ero B APYrnx KOMHCCHJIX, noToMy qTo TaM 3K3aMeffYJOTCJI H3 APYrHX qaCTee npeAMeTa, a oTMeTKa no K~oii 'laCTHHMeeT caoe 3HaqeHHe. BLmaeT TaK, qTo a OAHOH KOMHCCHH noJITH ace BLIAep:>KHBaIOT 3K3aMeH, nepexoAJIT B APYryio - npoaanHBaJOTcg. He gcHo JIH, tJTO 3AeCL JIHtJHOCTb 3K3aMeHaTopa HrpaeT 83)1('.HYIOpOJib? Mbl He 6yAeM pa36HpaTb npHtJHH, KOTOpbie HHOrAa AeJialOT MOJIOAbIX JIIOAeH )KepTBaMH KaKOro-HH6YAb CBHpenoro HJIH myTJIH-

BOrO 3K3aMeHaTopa. Mhl XOTeJIH TOJibKO noKa3aTb, qTo MO)KeT 6bITb MHoro cnyqaes, 06pa1.Qa10~ 3K3aMeHLI B noTepeio, a OHa BeAeT HHOrAa

H K m6eJibHbIM noCJieACTBHSIM'B tJeM y6eAHJI Hae HaCTO~H rOA. PaccMOTPeB, c KaKHMH ceo:HCTaaMH 6hlBaIOT 3K3aMeHaTopLI - pewH-

TeJIH CYAL6bl MOJIOAbIX JIIOAei, o6paTHM BHHMaHHe H Ha CaMYIO o6cTaHOBKY 3K3aMeffY10I.QerocJ1: oHa TaK)Ke HMeeT 3AecL 3HatJeHHe. MonoAoi qenoseK, eI.Qe He npHBbIKWHH roBOpHTb B 061.QeCTBe' TeM 6onee HrpaTb B HeM KaKYIO-JIH60 pOJib, BApyr AOJI)KeH JIBHTbCJI nocpeAH JIIOne:H, eMy MaJIO HJIH COBeeM He3HaKOMbIX, 6bITb npeAMeTOM BHHMaHHJI scex, OTBetJaTb Ha Bee BOnpOCbl H 3HaTb'lJTO Ka)l('.AblQOTBeT 6yAeT crporo o~eHHBaTbCjf; Bee 3TO He MO)KeT o60APHTeJibHO DOAeHCTBOBaTb Aa)Ke Ha qeJIOBeKa 6onee 3peJibIX JieT'oco6eHHO KOrAa npH 3TOM CTapalOTC$1 eI.Qe npffAaTb BeeMY AeJiy HeKOTopyio TOp)KeCTBeHHOCTb. HHOH IOHOWa KOe-KaK CJiaAHT co CBOHM 3aMHpaIOI.QHM AyxoM, co CBOHM APO)Kall\ffM, eABa CJiblWHLIM ronocoM, HaqHHaeT coo6pa)KaTb sonpocLI, 060Ap.s1Tbcg nepBLIMH yAatJHbIMH oTBeTaMH, BApyr Il03aAH Hero CKpHimyna ABepb, IlOAHHMaeTC$1 co CBOHX MeCT see CffAjfI.Qee - TO jfBJIJleTCjf KaKoe-JIH60 83)1('.HOeHJIH HatfaJibCTBYIOI.Qee JI~O; ero MYffAHP HJIH 3Be3Abl 6pocalOTCJI B rna3a MOJIOAOMY qeJIOBeKy; OH CHOBa CMYI.QaeTC$1, TepJ1eTcg; «qTO-TO 6yAeT» - eABa IlOAYMaeT OH, KaK y)Ke Bee HMelOI.Qee

npaBO CffAeTb OilJITb onycKaeTCJI Ha CBOH MecTa; OH OAHH OCTaeTCJI CTO-

.sw.uw, npHBJieKWH Ha ce6g BHHMaHHe H HOBOro JI~a; ero CHOBa HatJHHalOT cnpawHBan; OilJITL APO)KHT ronoc, OilJITb ffY)KHO AeJiaTL HaA co6oio oco6eHHhle YCHJIWI, llT06LI CKOJILKO-HH6YAL OBmlAeTL 006010, OIDITL IlLITKa•••

H TYT ffY)KHO noxa3aTL He TOJILKO caou no3HaHWI, HOH YMCTBeHHoe pa3BHTHe; a HHOrAa ffY)KHO H Ha6JIJOAaTb 3a co6oio, tfT06bI He OTcTaBHJiaCb KaKHH6YAb HeJIOBKO Hora, tJT06b1 APO)Kall\ffe pyKH 6LmH npHJIHqHo onyI.QeHLI, HHaqe MO)KeT IlOCJieAOBaTb 3aMe'laHHe,KOTOpoe COBCeM CKOHcpy3HT HHOro IOHOwy. q TO )Ke YAHBHTeJibHOro' eCJIH HHOrAa nyqWHe yqeHHKH 3AeCb OTBetJaIOT IlJIOXO Aa)Ke Ha aonpoCbl caoero Y'IHTeJIJI,KOTOpbIH npH 3TOM He CKpbIBaeT csoe:H AOCaAbl' lJTO 3K3aMeffYIOl.QHiCJI He onpaBAbIBaeT ero OTMeTKH nepeA HaqaJibCTBOM, TaK KaK HatfaJibCTBO tJaCTO cyAHT 0 npenOAaBaTeJIU no TaKHM 3K3aMeHaM • .IJ;ocaAa yqHTeJIJI He CKpOeTC$1OT3K3aMeHY-

B. SI . CTOIOHHH. MbICJIH o HawHx 3KJaMeHax

IOID;erocsr H He nonpaBHT ]l;ena.

3~alOTCSI TaIOKe H IlHCLMeHHLie pa6oTLI. IlOHSITHO'qTo OHH Tpe6yioT oco6eHHOro BHHMaHHSI co CTOpOHhl IlHWYID;HX. Ho He BCSIKaSI HaTYpa MO)KeT yrny6nSITbCSI B CBOH MhicnH H B TO )Ke BpeMSI cne]l;HTh 3a TeM, qTO BOKpyr ]l;enaeTCSI. 3aHSITLIH CBOHM TPYAOM, HHOH nerKo npo3esaeT BXOASIID;YIO HnH BhIXO)l;SIID;YIO oco6y'He nocnewHT BCTaTb H OT)l;aTh noqTeHHe'qTo ODSITb MO)KeT Bhl3BaTb 3aMe'IaHHe,a OHO Ha HHYIO po6Kyl0, CTbI)l;nHBYIO HnH qyaCTBHTenLHYIO HaTYPY MO)KeT DO)l;eHCTBOBaTb oqeHL He6naronpHSITHO ]l;nSI ycnewHoro npo]];On)KeHHSI pa6oTLI. Y)K H 6e3 roro, no-BH)l;HMOMY, AOBOnhHO pa3HhIX IlOBO)l;OB K CMyID;eHHIO HK IlOMexe. CaMoe TpeBO)KHOe COCTOSIHHe AYXa H TOMHTenLHOe O)KH]l;aHHe )l;On)KHO OKa3aTb He6naronpHSITHOe BnHSIHHe H Ha pa6oTy.

Ilocne 3K3aMeHa HaqHHaeTCSI coBeID;aHHe Me)K)l;y 3K3aMeHaTopaMH H accHcTeHTaMH. B ronosax HX cMeWHBalOTCSI pa3HLie cpH3HOHOMHH, MenLKalOT pa3HLie OTBeThl , H )l;enLHLie, H HenenL1e. ML1 He 3HaeM, eCTL nH B03-

MO)KHOCTL npHilOMHHTb Ka)K)l;YIO cpH3HOHOMHIO, qTo H KaK OTBeqan Ka~LIH, KaKoe noKa3a.n pa3BHTHe H np., oco6eHHO ecnH qffcno 3K3aMeHy-

IOID;HXCSI )l;OXOAHnO AO TpH)l;u;aTH, copoKa H 6onee . KoHeqHo, Ka)K)l;oMy npeno]l;aBaTenio nerKO DOMHHTb OTBeTbl CBOHX yqeHHKOB, HO Be)l;b TYT 6LmH H nHqHOCTH, cosepweHHO eMY He3HaKOMLie. CBHAeTensrMH sneqaTneHHSI, OCTaBneHHOro MOnO)l;blM qenoBeKOM, SIBnSllOTCSI MepTBLie ~HcppLI, KOTOpLie Tenepb H CBO)l;SITCSI BMeCTe. CoBeID;aHHe no 6onLweu qaCTH COCTOHT B ]l;eHCTBHH cno)KeHHSI H )l;eneHHSI, BhIBO)l;SITCSI cpe)l;HHe 6a.nnLI H3 OTMeTOK COBeID;aTenee, H HMH-TO H3peKaeTCSI nocne]l;HHH CYA Ha)]; IOHOWaMH. HHOr]l;a CBO)l;SITCSI OTMeTKH oqeHb HepaBHble 3a O)l;HH H Te )Ke OTBeTLI, KaK , HanpHMep'«4» H «2»; pa3'bSICHHTbTaKoe HepaBeHCTBO 6LIBaeT TpY)l;HO 3a MHO)KeCTBOM pa3HhIX OCTaBWHXCSI CMeWaHHLIX BneqaTneHHH , a D;Hcppa 3 He 6y)l;eT HHKOMY B 06H)l;y; OHa H nocny)KHT ou;eHKOIO MOnO)l;OMY qenoBeKy. 0 qpe3MepHOH CTpOrOCTH'c KaKOH HHhle ou;eHHBalOT OTBeTbl 3K3aMeHOBaBWHXCSI' He coo6pa)KaS1Ch c HX HCKJIIOqHTenLHbIM nono)KeHHeM, noqTH HHKOMY He npHXO)l;HTCSI rosopHTL, TaK KaK y scex Ha BH)l;Y HaqaJILCTBeHHOe npe]];nHcaHHe - HCDhlThIBaTb CTpO)Ke. Ha CTpOroCTh, KOHeqHo, HMelOT BnHSIHHe H ynHBepcHTeTCKHe noaepoqHLie HCnL1TaHHS1, TaK KaK HHKOMY He H3BeCTHO, KaKHM o6pa30M YHHBepcHTeT npOH3BO)l;HT CSOH noaepKH H Ha qTo o6paID;aeT oco6eHHOe BHHMaHHe. qTO, ecnH Ha noaepoqHOM HCilbITaHHH TaKOHTO OKa)KeTCSI cna6LIM, qTo, ecnH BhICTaBneHHblH eMy 6ann Haff)l;yT meAphlM? KoHellHO, yHHBepcHTeT OTHeceTCSI 06 3TOM K oKpy)KffOMY

HaqaJILCTBY' KOTOpoe TO~ac )Ke H npmnneT CBOH 3aMeqaHHSI COBeTY aoo6ID;e H 3K3aMeHaTopy·B oco6eHHOCTH. oLIBaJIH cnyqaH, qTo npeno]l;aBarenH nonyqa.nH C'rpOrHeIlHCLMeHHhle BbirOBOpbI qepe3 qeTblpe, DSITb neT nocne Toro, KaK yqeffHK BblWeJI H3 HX pyK; B KaKOM-TO ero npoweHHH K HaqaJILCTBY 6LmH YCMOTpeHLI )l;Be-TpH opcporpacpH'IecKHe OWH6KH H HenonHLIH KOMnneKT 3HaKOB npenHHaHHSI. TaKHM o6pa30M, HaA ne]l;aroraMH DOCTOSIHHO BHCHT MOJIOT' KOTOpbIM OAYPSllOT HX 3a ue6pe)KHOCTH )l;a)Ke HX 6LIBWHX yqeuHKOB. Y cTauoaneuHe yuHsepcHTeTCKHX nosepoqHLIX HCilhlTaHHH DOKa3LIBaeT He]l;OBepHe K rnMHa3H'IeCKHM 3K3aMeHaM. B

B. 51 . CTOIOHHH

TaKOM cnyqae 3aqeM )Ke 6hIJIO nepeAaBaTb BCT}'nHTeJibHhieB YHHBepCHTeT 3K3aMeHhI H3 pyK yHHBepcHTeTCKHX npocpeccopoB B pyKH mMHa3K'leCKHX npenOAaBaTeJieH H 3atieM )Ke AOnycKaTb K AeJiy TaKHe JIH~a, KOTOpbie He

3aCJiy)KHBalOT AOBepm1? B neAarorHtieCKOM OTHOWeHHH 3TO 3JIO HeHcnpaBHMOe. B~nHTaTeJibHOe AeJIO MO)KeT 6hITb OCHOBaHO TOJibKO Ha AOBepHH

K BOCilHTaTemlM, ecJIH )Ke ero HeT, TO HeT H BOCilHTaTeJILHOH CHCTeMbl, HeT H pa3yMH()ro BOCnHTaHWI; eCTb TOJihKO qHHOBHHKH, HaA KOTOpbIMH uy:>KeH IlOCTOSIHHLIH KOHTPOJih, tIT06 BCe B CBOeH BHeWHOCTH H cpopMaJibHOCTH o6CTOSIJIO 6narononyquo.

IloHSITHO, qTo npH tIHHOBHHtILHX OTHoweHWIX Ha qenoBeKa CMOTPSIT, KaK Ha BeI.Qh, KaK Ha MaWHHY'IlOTOMY c HHM H o6paI.QalOTCSl KaK c BeI.QhlO

HJIH MaWHHOH. qTO 3a OXOTa H3-3a KaKOrO-HH6YAh c 0 M H HT e JI b H 0 r 0

lOHOWH nonyqaTL BbirOBOpbI, 3aMeqaHWI H, MO:>KeT 6LITh, JIHWaTLCSl HarpaA ! B 3TOM cnyqae ropa3AO BLirOAHee YMeHhWHTh pHcK nonaAaThCSl uaqanhCTBY H Aep:>KaThCSl HeyMoJIHMOH CTPOrOCTH.

l13 3TOro KpaTKOro oqepKa caM co6010 BhITeKaeT OTBeT Ha BOnpOCLI: YAOBJieTBopS110T JIH Hawn 3K3aMeHhI TPe60BaHHS1M rocyAapcTBa H 061.QeCTBa' KOTOpLie HY~alOTCSl B H3BeCTHLIX CHJiax H KOTOpbie AalOT JIH\IHOCTSIM 3a 3TH CHJihI H3BeCTHLie npaBa? MoryT JIH uawH 3K3aMeHhI Bnonue BepHO o~eHHBaTb CHJibl H He nponycKaTh BnepeA TOJILKO CHJILI AeHCTBH-

TeJihHO cna6h1e? MoryT JIH HM COBepweHHO AOBepSITb HaWH ceMeHCTBa, BOCnHTbIBalOI.QHe 3TH CHJibl H B03JiaralO~He Ha HHX CBOH HaAe~LI?

HecocroS1TeJILHOCTh HX TaK oqeBimHa, tITO uanpacuo 6bmo 6b1 AOJiee o Hen pacnpOCTPalUITLCSl . .s:ICHO, 11TO TaKaSI CHCTeMa AOJI:>KHa 6bITb 3aMeHeHa Apyrou'rAe cnyqanHOCTH He MOrJIH 6LI HMeTh BJIHSITeJILHOH CHJILI H rAe 60- nee HMeJICSl 6LI B BRAY )KHBOH q e JI 0 Be K co CBOeH AyxOBHOH npHpOAOH .

ML1 BffAeJIH, 11To He6naronpHS1moe BJIIDIHHe Ha oTBeThI MOJIOAOro ·1eJIOBeKa oqeHh qacro OKa3LIBaeT crpax, HHOrAa HeBOJILHhIH, 6e3oTqeTHLIH, HHOrAa H3 HeyBepeHHOCTH B caMOM ce6e, HHOrAa H3 caMOJII06IDI H np. KoHeqHo, YHHtITO)KHTL 3TO qyBCTBO HeB03MO:>KHo, HO, HaM Ka:>KeTcSl, eCTh B03MO:>KHOCTb ocna6HTb ero, ycrpaHHB Bee TO, qTo o6LIKHOBeHHO ero ycHJIHBaeT HJIH no,rmep:>KHBaeT. Y:>Ke OAHO 3TO npHHeceT 3HaqnTeJihHoe }:\06po H ;a;acT 66nhwyio pa3yMHOCTh caMOMY ;a;eny. B HaCTOSII.Qee BpeMSl Ka~hIH

3K3aMeHy10I.QHHCS1 CTaBHTCSl B nono:>KeHHe aKTepa-Ae610TaHTa. Pa3HH~a Me~y HHMH B TOM, tITO nocneAHHH A06pOBOJILHO BLICrynaeT Ha ny6JIHqHLIH CYA, y:>Ke BLI6pae ce6e TaKylO Kapbepy'npH 3TOM OH npH3HaeT B ce6e KaKon-nH6o TaJiaHT, OH 3HaeT, 11TO eM) Hy)l{Ho 6y;a;eT roeopHTL, 11To y Hero eCTb no,rmep:>KKa B cycpnepe, 11TO ero HHKTO He CMYTHT KaKHM-JIH60 HeO:>KHAaHHhIM BODpOCOM H np.'a 3K3aMeHylOI.QHHCSl, KOHeqeo, MOJIO:>Ke Ae6roTaHTa, HMeJI MeHee cny11aeB 6LIBaTL B 061.QeCTBe, COBepweHHO AJISI Hero 11y:>KoM; OH HAeT Ha ny6JIHtIHhIH cy;a; He no BOJie, a no Heo6xo;a;HMOCTH, noToMy tITO ;a;pyrou ;a;opom eMy HeT. K0He11eo, y ;a;e610TaHTa 6onee ny6JIHtIHOCTH, 6onee cy;a;eu, HO JaTo y Hero H 6onee no;a;;a;ep:>KKH, JaTo H Heycnex ;a;nSl Hero He HMeeT TaKoro pewHTeJILHoro 3eaqeHHS1, KaK AJISI MOJio;a;oro qeJIOBeKa," HAYI.Qero Ha 3K3aMeH, OKpY:>KeHHOro, c O]l;HOH CTopoHhI, 3K3aMeHaTopaMH H Ha11aJibCTBOM, c ;a;pyrou - MOJIOAhIMH JIIOAhMH,

B. SI . CTOIOHHH . M brcnH o HawHx 3KJaMettax

XOTSI H 6e3 npaBa ronoca, HO BCe )Ke JIIOAbMH, Ha KOTOpMX CTbIAHO 6yAeT nocMOTPeTb B cnyqae Heycnexa. HTaK, noJio)KeHne Ae610raHTa BhirOAHee; a KTO H3 HHX cKa)KeT, tITO eM)'YAaJIOCh 6e3 CHJihHoro crpaxa BhICTynHTh Ha

CQeHy, tITO CTJ'axHe oKa3hIBaJI AYPHOro BJIIDIHHSI Ha ero urpy, u pa3Be He 6bIJIO CJI~aeB' tITO nepBbie Ae6IOTbl OtieHb TaJiaHTJIHBbIX aKTepoa 6hmH He COBCeM YAatIHhI; po60CTb, CMy~eHHe, C1'paXnoMeWaJIH HM BbIKa3aTh CBOH

CHJihI. Ho AJISI aKTepa BCSI 3Ta ny6nHtIHOCTh HeH36e)KHa, c HeIO cnuaaeTcsr ero nonpu~e. A pa3Be HeT B03MO)KHOCTH yMeHblliHTb ee'paimo KaK H BCJO

Ka3eHHYIO TOp)KeCTBeHHOCTh npu 3K3aMeHax? Pa3Be He npeAnoqen 6bI

K~blH MOJIOAOH qeJIOBeK TaKOH CJIOBeCHbIH 3K3aMeH, KOTOpbIH 6bl noxoAHJI 6onee Ha 6eceAy, tieM Ha cypoBoe BhinhIThIBaHne HJIH Aa)Ke Ha nbITKY, a 3K3aMeH IlHCLMeHHblH - Ha cnoKOHHYIO pa6ory B co6CTBeHHOM Ka6HHe-

Te, rAe MO)KHO yrny6HTbCSI B CBOH MbIC.TIH, He HMeSI nepeA co60IO HHKaKoro 3peJIH~a, rAe MO)KHO cnOKOHHO BCTaTb co caoero MeCTa, npoiiTHCb no KOM-

HaTe 6e3 CTJ'Ororo u noA03pHTeJILHoro Ha6JIIOAaTensr. Mhl 3HaeM, tITO tIHHOBHHKH-neAarorH 6YAYT 3a~u~aTb 3TO CTOSIHHe HaBblTSl)KKY nepeA 3eJieHLIM CTOJIOM, 3TH tIHHOBHO-HatiaJihHHtieCKHe OTHOllieHIDI K MOJIOAhIM JIIOASIM; OHH 6YAYT HaCTOHtIHBO AOKa3bIBaTL .He06XOAHMOCTh nOAAep)KHBaTb TaKHM o6pa30M cBoe n e A a r o r H q e c K o e 3HatieHne; HM rroKa- )KeTcSI C1'paHHOIOAa)Ke MbICJih AOnycTHTb 6eceAy c KaKHM-HH6YAh MaJibtIHKOM, H npHTOM 6e3 HaA30pa co CTOpOHLI BCero HatiaJILCTBa. Ho 3THM caMbIM OHH TOJibKO AOK~T' tITO OHH He noHHMalOT AeHCTBHTeJibHOH neAaroruu, tITO AJISI HHX BCUK.Hee Bcero OTBJietieHHhIH npHHQHn: noru6aii nyqmue CHJibl. TOJihKO OCTaJICSI 6bI HenpHKOCHOBeHeH OH, 3TOT rrpHHQHil '

KOTOpbIH caM' nocJie 3ApaBOH KpHTHKH' MO)KeT OKa3aTLCSI rHHJlblM HJIH MepTBSl~HM B neAaromqecKOM Aene. HM HenoHSITHO, tITO HCTHHHLIH neAa-

ror noMep)KHBaeT K ce6e yBa)KeHne, notITeHHe H AOBepHe APYrHMH cnoco-

6aMH, KOTOpbIX y HHX, MO)KeT 6hITh, HeT, H rroToMy OHH AYMaIOT CBSl3LIBaTL c poJILIO neAarora He HAY~IO K Heii ponh reHepana. HM xoTeJIOCh 6h1

IlOCTaBHTb HaBblTSl)KKY H Bcex neAaroroB, a 0 IOHOWax, npHBJieKaeMbIX K 3K3aMeHy, H roBopHTh Hetiero. Ho, HecMOTJ'SIHa Bee 3TO, MbI pemaeMcsr yKa3aTb Ha HHYIO CHCTeMy 3K3aMeHOB, y6e)f{AeHHbie, tITO AeHCTBHTeJibHbie neAaroru BO MHoroM AaAyT eli npeAIIOtITeHHe nepeA crapo10; AJISI Hae )Ke TOJibKO 3TO H Ba)KHO, nOTOMY tITO BeCTH npaBHJibHO 3K3aMeHbl, c nOJib30IO AJISI ecex, MOryT JIHllib OAHH HaCTOSl~He ne~arom, KOTOpbie noHHMalOT qeJIOBetiecKyIO npupoAy< ... >

YcrpaIDBI, cxon1> B03MO}f{HO, ny6JIHtIHOCTL H TOp}KeCTBeHHOCTL, HY}KHO no3a60THTbCS1 u 06 yc1'paHeHHHHepaeeHCTBa Me)f{Ay 3K3aMeHyIO~HMHCSI. ECJin B OAHOH H TOH )Ke rnMHa3HH 6oJihlliHHCTBO 3K3aMeHyIO~Hxcsr B OAHOH

KOMHCCHH BbJAep)KHBaeT 3K3aMeH, a TYT }Ke PSIAOM B Apyroli II p 0 B a JI H - Bae Tc SI, TO TeM CKOpee H Jier"tJe MO)KeT CJI~aTbCSI 3TO B pa3HbIX rHMHa3HSIX: OAHa CJiaBHTCSI CTJ'OfOCTblO HCilbITaHHH , Apyrasr 60JihWelO JierKOCTbIO; B OAHY C1'peWITCSIH npOCSITCSI MOJIOAbie JIIOAH, Apyro:H H36eraIOT. Ha3HatieHHLie B C1'pOry10mMHa3HIO 1'penell:(YT,Ha3Ha"tJeHHble e nerKyIO 6narocnoBJIS110T CYAL6y. MB caMoM AeJie, 3TH CJiy'tlaHHOCTHHe HMeIOT JIH BHA CYAb6bI H eCTb JIH 3TO caMaSI BbICWaSI HecrrpaBeAJIHBOCTh no OTHOme-