!!Экзамен зачет 2023 год / Слыщенков. Договор к-п-1
.pdf<3> Ibid. P. 681.
, ,
,
nemo dat;
" (ostensible authority) <1>
.
.
,
nemo dat, . . 24, 25 (1) 1979 .
(
),
, . ,
:
.
--------------------------------
<1> . . 174 ,
nemo dat .
,
.
, .
:
; ,
.
;
,
. , "
" (possession is nine tenth of the law), ,
.
,
.
. ,
,
,
.
5.3.
XIX .
. caveat emptor
, , ,
, ,
.
, . caveat emptor ,
.
1893 . <1>.
(implied warranty of title)
<2>. ,
, ,
(property) <3> ( . 2 1979 .) <4> , ,
( . 12) <5>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 155 sq.; Powell R. Eviction in Roman Law and English law // Studies in the Roman Law of Sale. Dedicated to the Memory of Francis de Zulueta / Ed. by D. Daube. Oxford, 1959. P. 87 - 89; Rowland v Divall [1923] 2 K.B. 500, 505.
<2> .: Lawson F.H. Op. cit. P. 365.
<3> Lawson F.H., Rudden B. (Op. cit. P. 57): "
" (ownership) the property in the goods ( )
title to goods "; ,
(ownership)
, " "
, , the owner of a legal mortgage (Ibid. P. 9092). property (Ibid. P. 20):
(bailee) " " (special property),
, , "
" (general property) (Ibid. P. 81).
<4> 2 (1): " - ,
, ".
<5> 12: "(1) ...
(implied term) ,
(sale) ,
(agreement to sell) ,
(when the property is to pass). (2)
... (implied term),
(a) ,
, (charge or encumbrance),
, (b) ,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
,
,
".
12 (1) 1979 . ,
" " (right to sell) . ,
. ,
, ,
, " ",
<1>.
,
. " "
(power) .
nemo dat quod non habet,
. 12 (1) 1979 .
<2>.
--------------------------------
<1> Niblett v Confectioners' Materials Co [1921] 3 K.B. 387; .: Miles R. Op. cit. P. 207; Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 104.
<2> .: Miles R. Op. cit. P. 206 - 207; Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 104 - 105; . Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 169.
1979 .
. , . 12 (1)
(
), " " (condition), " " <1>;
, . 12 (1)
,
. , .
12 (2) , ,
" " " " (warranty) <2>.
,
,
<3>.
--------------------------------
<1> . 11 (3) 1979 .: "
(condition),
, (warranty),
,
,
;
(condition), (warranty)". <2> 12 (5A) 1979 .
<3> 11 1979 .; .: Rowland v Divall [1923] 2 K.B. 500, 505; Miles R. Op. cit. P. 208, 210; Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 105, 110.
, (
) <1>.
, Rowland v Divall <2>,
. 12 (1)
, (action for money had and received). ,
,
, ( ,
). .
; ,
<3>.
(total failure of consideration) <4>.
, ,
( ) <5>.
--------------------------------
<1> 62 (2) 1979 . <2> [1923] 2 K.B. 500.
<3> .: Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 941 - 943, 1056 - 1057;
( ) .: Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 530 - 534; Birks P. Failure of consideration // Consensus Ad Idem. Essays in the Law of Contract / Ed. by F.D. Rose. London, 1996. P. 188, n. 30.
<4> Chandler v Webster [1904] Q.K.B. 943,
,
(void ab initio),
Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna v Fairbairn Lawson Combe Barbour Ltd [1943] A.C. 32 ( .: Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 510 - 511).
<5> .: Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 1049; Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit.
P.500, 515 - 517.
Rowland v Divall
, .
, ,
(total failure of consideration)
,
. (Atkin) :
, ,
, .
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
, , .
, de facto ,
, , " <1>. <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> [1923] 2 K.B. 500, 506.
<2> Karflex, Limited v Poole [1933] 2 K.B. 251; Butterworth v Kingsway Motors; Hayton, Third Party; Kennedy, Forth Party; Rudolph, Fifth Party [1954] 1 W.L.R 1286; Warman v Southern Counties Car Finance Corporation Ld. W.J. Ameris Car Sales (Third Party) [1949] 2 K.B. 576 .
Rowland v Divall
-
.
,
. ;
Butterworth v Kingsway Motors <1>,
( ) ,
<2>. .
,
, ;
,
, ( ,
, )
<3>, <4>.
--------------------------------
<1> [1954] 1 W.L.R 1286.
<2> (P. 1291), "
" (lacking in merits).
<3> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 107.
<4> , , ,
(Op. cit. P. 107): Rowland v Divall (P. 505)
,
, ,
. ; ,
,
( . : Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 159). , ,
(consumption)
(accessio) ( .: Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 529).
,
( ,
), ,
. , ,
<1>. ,
, (
, ,
) <2>. ,
(Law Reform Committee),
,
, ? ,
. 12 (1) 1979 .
(law of conversion), ,
.
. 12 1979 .,
<3>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 529; Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 1055.
<2> .: Goff R., Jones G. Op. cit. P. 529; Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 1056.
<3> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 108 - 109.
Rowland v Divall (
: " , ... (sale) ,
(right to sell).
- (property) " <1>) :
.
)
.
Rowland v Divall , ,
.
--------------------------------
<1> Rowland v Divall [1923] 2 K.B. 500, 506 - 507.
National Employers' Mutual General Insurance Association Ltd. v Jones <1> (Denys Buckley) :
, ,
,
(law), , .
,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
" <2>.
<3>. (sale),
, <4>,
<5>.
--------------------------------
<1> [1990] 1 AC 24. <2> Ibid. P. 50.
<3> .: Goode R. Commercial Law. London, 2004. P. 200: " ,
, , ,
"; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 167, 169 - 170.
<4> Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 167: " (agreement for the sale) res aliena, (actual sale), (not null and void)".
<5>
1979 . .: Battersby G., Preston A.D. Op. cit. P. 270 - 275; Goode R. Op. cit. P. 199 - 202.
,
.
.
5.4., ,
,
. 28
1979 . ,
" <1>.
, ,
,
. ,
. 39 (1) 1979 .
.
,
, . Bloxam v Sanders ,
, : "
], ,
, . ?
[ ],
, ,
, " <2>.
.
--------------------------------
<1> "
, .
". " " (concurrent conditions) , "
" ( .: Treitel G. Remedies for Breach of Contract. P. 277).
<2> (1825) 4 B. & C. 941, 948, . : Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 723.
, ,
(lien),
, , ( . 41
1979 .). ,
,
,
. 43 1979 .). ,
, . , ,
( . 44). . 48 (1)
. , ,
,
. 1979 .,
" " (warranty), " " (condition). ,
,
<1>.
,
<2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 752.
<2> .: Miles R. Op. cit. P. 289; Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 465.
, ,
, ),
( ,
). , ,
, <1>.
,
, .
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
,
<2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 748 - 749, 757 - 758. <2> Ibid. P. 755 - 757.
, (lien),
,
,
. , ,
,
, ,
.
,
.
. ,
-
. ,
,
<1>.
; ,
. ,
,
.
(own) ,
" <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 751; Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 42. Para 178; . : Lysaght v Edwards (1875 - 1876) 2 Ch. D. 499, 507.
<2> Gray K., Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 750, K.L.D.E. Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Queensland) (1984) 155 CLR 288.
* * *
(retention reservation of title clause)
,
.
. . 17 19 1979 .
,
.
" " (right of disposal)
". ,
.
, 1970- . Aluminium Industrie v Romalpa Aluminium Ltd. <1>
.
25 <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> [1976] 1 W. L. R. 676.
<2> .: Davies I. United Kingdom // Retention of Title Clauses in Sale of Goods Contracts in Europe / Ed. by I. Davies. Aldershot, 1999. P. 101.
.
,
,
, (charge), <1>.
,
.
,
( ) <2>. (charges),
,
1985 .). "
" <3>. ,
(
)
Clough Mill Ltd v Martin <4>. ,
, ,
, , ,
,
<5>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 476. <2> .: Davies I. Op. cit. P. 102.
<3> Ibid. P. 104.
<4> [1984] 3 All ER 982.
<5> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 478.
. ,
,
,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )