Gospodarske_procesyalne_pravo-Sheluhin

= 34. $ $ ' + ' + " "-
*"#($ ( & !& – B' ( & !& , >#('?D! $ D #D=.?"#) %> !(
( =#%>#"! %C+ F %*"!F, ?+$ >#+.!"!E&C%? ! % # ,
& '&$ #%#I D %!)#%&$H ) ( )#=!) D )'E ,F ($"G+#"*(! ? "' <!($
&! %># *+! ? D!B$+!(.' ?F #%$I "# ( '=*.E(! ? %># $(
* ($">#($" #%&$ $D D!+# #"!(%&(#) I'D (& *A! ? %*"*
-? " = –
B' #I#(’?D+#( H $ "$EA H ! (%$H
&' $, + !, >.!&$<	-, * "’$&
D! D"$H% ' ? E " A #	& -&@$+ = '*-" , –
D !A*L F "$H, L# (A ?E&C%?	B' %*) , ?+$ >$".?=!E&C %>.!&$ p!
=#%>#"! %C+ ) %*"!)
># #D=.?"*, ( $G' E &!
>' '=.?"* =#%>#"! %C+ F %> !(
I#(’?D+#( H >.!&$< D! "$, =#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"*
&= - "' " F & =
D!.'< &C ($" B$ >#D#(*
Q! !F#(*T&C%? "# ' <!( #=# IE"<'&* + !,
#('"' ? %*"#(#, '+%>' & D
=.?" &! "#%.$"<' ? 'A#( F "#+!D$( ( )$%B$ ,F D !F#"<' ?
#%.*= >' '+.!"!A!
# )!B$H #-&'F $A ' D!I'D>'A' ? > #B'%*
#%.*= !"(#+!&!
G$ ( & !& , >#(’?D! $ D #D=.?"#) %> !(
#+ (!E&C '!.C $ ( & !& , >#(’?D! $ D > #B'%*!.C ) "$?)
D !A!E&C%? !+& A # > #('"' ) ( & !&!)
>.!A*E&C%? #%#I$, ?+! > H)!T *A!%&C * %> !($ &! ># '%.!
($">#($" $ ( & !& !I# I'D>#%' '" C# '+%>' &!),
>' '+.!"!A!) &! $ .

51

= 35. * +-? " @ =

-? " = = = * D A /'$

& " &$"

(%&. 45 &! >. 2 %&. 3 '+ '&* !I$ '&* $ $%& $( + !, ( )

“ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

$" *- "?$ & * ? & + "

( %&. 45 &! >. 2 %&. 3 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

*$% F ' % F	'-@
( %&. 45 &! >. 2 %&. 3

“ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

$" *- *-@$+ ' + " - C / & " "$" = ' " = (>. 2 %&. 3

“ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

= 36. + +-? " @ =

-? " = * + $E /'$ +" " +

-' –		-*-% F –
		) , %*)! ?+#=#
) , L# %&?=*T&C%?		#IA %.ET&C%? * > #B' & #)*
( &(' "$H %*)$		%>$(($" #G' $ "# %*) ,
		L# #%># ET&C%?
	52

= 37. &= - +-? " @ =

-" " & D$ +-? " @ =

"-+ ' " " +' " + % * & "

D >#D#( F ( )#= )!H #(#=# F! !+&' *

-&= - , -= * + " " = = = = + + " @-= +$

;& * & " &$" = F " @ - -, " #)* A %.$:

$D D!?( > # ( D ! ? '"$H% ) >#( $%&E !I# A!%&+#(# !+&$( ' # )!& ( #=# F! !+&' *;

$D D!?( + '" $( > # ># *G' ? %> !( > # I! + *&%&(#;

$D D!?( + '" $(, ?+$ D(' &!E&C%? D )!H #( ) ( )#=!) "# I# < +! >$%.? #=#.#G' ? ># *G' ? %> !( > # I! + *&%&(#

D >#D#( F D!?( ># %># !F, L# ( +!E&C > *+.!"! $, D)$ $ !I# #D$ (! $ =#%>#"! %C+ F "#=#(# $(

($"%#&+!F

*$% F ' % F '-@ - C$,

*F(!. &! >#%&! #(

;& &$" *- ! *-@$+ & " "$" =

#I%&!( !)

53

= 38. " +-? " @ =

#D)$ %&!(#+ "' <!( #=# ) &! $D D!?(,

M * + A /'$ + @ '* +-'/ ' + " (*. 2 ' . 3 “- +-? " = ”)

D >#D#( F D!?( )!H #(#=# F! !+&' * –

1 ($"%#+ B$ >#D#(*, !.' ' )' G 3-F '#>#"!&+#(*(! F )$ $)*)$( "#F#"$( = #)!"? $ ' I$.CG'

100-&! '#>#"!&+#(*(! F )$ $)*)$( "#F#"$( = #)!"?

;& * & " &$" = F " @ - -, " = D ' :

$D D!?( > # ( D ! ? '"$H% ) >#( $%&E !I# A!%&+#(# !+&$( ' # )!& ( #=# F! !+&' *;

$D D!?( + '" $( > # ># *G' ? %> !( > # I! + *&%&(#;

$D D!?( + '" $(, ?+$ D(' &!E&C%? D )!H #( ) ( )#=!) "# I# < +! >$%.? #=#.#G' ? ># *G' ? %> !( > # I! + *&%&(# –

5 '#>#"!&+#(*(! F )$ $)*)$( "#F#"$( = #)!"?

;& * & " &$" * '*-=, M " A / * + D ' +$, &= -& -"$ @ '* +-'/ + @ "- " –

5 '#>#"!&+#(*(! F )$ $)*)$( "#F#"$( = #)!"?

D !>'.?B$H F $ +!%!B$H F %+! = ! $G' ?

* ' " , ? &$" *- *-@$+ ! & " "$" = ' " = –

50 ($"%#&+$( %&!(+ , L# >$".?=!T %>.!&$ * !D$ >#"! ? D!?( ".? #D=.?"* %># * ( >' G$H $ %&! B$,

D %># $( )!H #(#=# F! !+&' * –

50 ($"%#&+$( %&!(+ , #IA %.' #, ( F#"?A D

#%># E(! #, %*)

54

= 39. "- $ +-? " @ = & A+?

+' " * "- $ +-? " @ = & A+?

(' . 8 “- +-? " = ”)

'%' ? ) &! * I$.CG F #D)$ !F,

$< >' '"I!A' # A ) D!+# #"!(%&(#)

"- $ &$" ('-@ ) " += " " !!

*- H ?&&$

-*$ *-" +?$ '*-" & C$

>#D#(* I'D #D=.?"*, ?+L# %> !(! ' >$".?=!T

#D=.?"* ( =#%>#"! %C+#)* %*"$

' "$ " ' " = *-$+ - C$

' + , $M *- %/ = +-? " = "?

'$@

= 40. - L-= % F- D & &* D$ *-% '

&= - "- L-= % F- D

& &* D$ ' + " @ *-% '

( #%&! #(! !I$ '&* $ $%& $( + !, ($" 29 I' 'D ? 2002 #+*

“ # ( D !A' ? #D)$ * ( & !& ! $ # )!B$H #-&'F $A '

D!I'D>'A' ? %*"#(#=# > #B'%*”)

0 @-" / –

".? #%$I, ?+$ D=$" # D D!+# #"!(%&(#) D($.C ?E&C%?

($" %>.!& "' <!( #=# ) &! > D(' ' $

"# =#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"*

118 @-" / –

".? (%$F $ G F #%$I, L# D(' &!E&C%? "#

=#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"* D! D!F %) %(#,F ># *G' F

> !( &! #F# # E(! F D!+# #) $ &' '%$(

55

= 41. " /$ " + '* +-? " @ =

$" %>.!& "' <!( #=# ) &! ># %> !(!F,

M -&@$+ A /'$ " @ '* +-'/ ' + , &" /$A /'$

'% " +-? " += '-% !

D! >#D#(!) "# =#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"* > # ( D ! ?

'"$H% ) !+&$( # =! $( )$%B'(#=# &! '=$# !.C #=#

%!)#( ?"*(! ?, L# %*>' 'A!&C A #)* D!+# #"!(%&(*

(>. 12 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

U$ ! %#($ # =! &! "' <!( $ >#"!&+#($ $ %>'+B$, –

>#D (!A$ H ($">#($"!A$ –

D! >#D#(!) "# %*"* !I# =#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"*

(>.15 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

=! "' <!( #=# +# & #.E D! B$ !) –

>#D (!A$ H ($">#($"!A$ –

D! >#D#(!) "# %*"* &! =#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"*

(>. 17 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

-/ *- - - -! !! -@ –

D! >#D#(!) , D ?+ ) (# D(' &!E&C%? "# %*"* !I# =#%>#"! %C+#=# %*"* ( $ &' '%!F = #)!"? &! "' <!( (>. 30 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

!B$# !.C H I! + + !, &! H#=# *%&! #( ,

D! ( ?&+#) =#%> #D !F* +#( F

(>. 29 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

' %$H H # " + !, , H#=# >$"> T)%&(!,

' " F -@ & % !; Q + -! ' % / @

& ' " + " F @ " ++ $

(>. 34 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

& )# #>#.C H +#)$&'& + !, &! H#=# &' & - - / " ++ $ – >#D (!A$ &! ($">#($"!A$ –

D! >#D#(!) ( %*" &! =#%>#"! %C+ H %*" (>. 36 %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”)

; C ' ’E , M *-+ D

* %&. 4 “ # "' <!( ' ) ”

56

= 42. - , * "’$& & - &@ $+ = '*- " ,

* -$+ ! " & D $

-, * "’$& & -&@$+ = '*-" @ '* +-'/ =

' + =, ! ' + " *-$+ " & D$

-, M * +$@ A / '* & *-" +$ ' + " !

'+%>' & D , > D !A' #, =#%>#"! %C+ ) %*"#)

!=# #"* D! #I#&*, ( +# ! * '+%>' &!) , ( D !A!T

=#%>#"! %C+ H %*" D * !F*(! ?) %&!(#+ $ #+.!"$(, (%&! #(.' F

'+%>' & #E *%&! #(#E, ! &!+#< ( D!.'< #%&$ ($" +(!.$ $+!B$,

!F$(B$(, %+.!" #%&$ &! #I%?=* ( +# ! #, #I#& , !.' ' ( L'

#D)$ *, (%&! #(.' #=# D!+# #"!(%&(#)

& !& , L# >$".?=!E&C %>.!&$ >' '+.!"!A!)

*)* ( D !A!T =#%>#"! %C+ H %*", !.' ' ( L' %*) ,

(%&! #(.' #, D!+# #"!(%&(#)

& !& , L# >$".?=!E&C ($"G+#"*(! E '+%>' &!), >' '+.!"!A!)

! &$%&C > #,D"* "# )$%B? ( +. +* $ !D!" D!.$D A ),

!()#I$.C ) $ >#($& ? ) & ! %># )

! &$%&C >#>' '" C#=# > #"!<* > #,D F "#+*)' &$(

#,D" !()#I$.C ) & ! %># ) (+ $) &!+%$)

"# D!.$D A #, %&! B$,, !' #># &*, ?+L# (#

D !F#"?&C%? D! )'<!) !%'.' #=# >* +&*

!H)! ? < .#=# > )$L' ?, D=$" # D # )!) , (%&! #(.' )

".? ($"G+#"*(! ? ( & !& ! %.*<I#($ ($" ?"<' ?

" -&= -, "' " & + "' " =

> # %.*<I#($ ($" ?"<' ?

-, * "’$& & @$+ = + ' +?$=

'A#( F "#+!D$( ( )$%B$ ,F D !F#"<' ?

/ &- "- *- $" ' + = ",

L# ,F >$"&(' "<*E&C

- L-= % F- D & &* D$

%*"#(#=# > #B'%*

D !A!E&C%? !I$ ') $ $%& $( + !,

& !& , L# >$".?=!E&C %>.!&$ D! >#%.*= !"(#+!&!

& D A /'$ *-$+ , "' " =

Q!+# #) + !, “ # !"(#+!&* *”

57

= 43. &* + @ '* +-'/ "-

-" -&* + @ '* +-'/ "-

' <!( ' ) >#+.!"!T&C%?

'*-, M " A / *- + , &=

-& -" + @ "- ", –

! % # *, ?+! I'D>$"%&!( # *F .?T&C%? ($" > H ?&&?

> #>#D B$, $ G#, % # , !I# ! #I "($ % # , ?+L#

=#%>#"! %C+ ) %*"#) ($"F .' # A!%& * > #>#D B$H

+#< #, $D % $

'*-, M " A / *- " + @ "- "

& C * +' ", –

! % # > #># B$H # #D)$ * D!"#(#.' ?

>#D#( F ( )#=

]+L# %>$ ( + ( !%.$"#+ '> !(#)$ F "$H % # ,

=#%>#"! %C+ H %*" )!T > !(# >#+.!%& ! ', "' <!( ' )

'D!.'< # ($" 'D*.C&!&$( ( $G' ? %># *

' <!( ' ) , ($" %>.!& ?+#=# >#D (!A * (%&! #(.' #)* ># ?"+*

D($.C ' H, %&?=*T&C%? D ($">#($"!A! ( "#F#" IE"<'&*

> #># B$H # #D)$ * D!"#(#.' F ( )#=, ?+L# ($">#($"!A

' D($.C ' H ($" %>.!& "' <!( #=# ) &!

# $, ! +# %&C ?+#, ($"I*.#%? $G' ?, =#%>#"! %C+ H %*"

($"G+#"#(*T ) D! !F* #+ " *=#, % # $ ( )* ( >!"+*,

+#. " *=! % # ! D($.C ' ! ($" H#=# %>.!&

*) , ?+$ >$".?=!E&C %>.!&$ D! > #('"' ? %*"#(#, '+%>' & D ,

>#%.*= >' '+.!"!A!, !"(#+!&!, ( & !& ! $ # )!B$H #-

&'F $A ' D!I'D>'A' ? %*"#(#=# > #B'%* &! $ G$ ( & !& ,

>#(’?D! $ D #D=.?"#) %> !( , >#+.!"!E&C%?:

D!"#(#.' $ >#D#(* –! ($">#($"!A!

($")#($ ( >#D#($ –! >#D (!A!

A!%&+#(#)* D!"#(#.' $ >#D#(* – ! #I "($ % # > #># B$H # #D)$ * D!"#(#.' F >#D#( F ( )#=

58

= 44. $ $ " + + & " @ '* +-'/ = *-% '
	#+!D * %> !($ –
B' I*"C-?+$ !+& A $ "! $, ! >$"%&!($ ?+ F =#%>#"! %C+ H %*"
* ( D !A' #)* D!+# #) ># ?"+* (%&! #(.ET !?( $%&C A
($"%*& $%&C #I%&!( , ! ?+ F W * &*E&C%? ( )#= $
D!>' 'A' ? % $ , ! &!+#< $ G$ #I%&!( , ?+$ )!E&C
D !A' ? ".? > !( .C #=# ( $G' ? =#%>#"! %C+#=# %># *
" "#+!D$( * =#%>#"! %C+#)* > #B'%$
%C)#($	#?% ' ? > '"%&!( +$(
	% $ &! $ G F #%$I, ?+$
'A#($	I' *&C *A!%&C * %*"#(#)*
	> #B'%$ ( ! ( )#=* %*""$
% #(+ %*"#( F	>#?% ' ? )#<*&C I*&
'+%>' &$(	( +.!"' $ > %C)#(#)
)#= , L# > '"’?(.?E&C%? "# "#+!D$(

? ' / + & " –

=#%>#"! %C+ H %*"

> H)!T . G' &$ "#+!D , ?+$ )!E&C D !A' ? ".? %> !(

#>*%& )$%&C "#+!D$( – #I%&!( %> !( , ?+$ ($">#($" # "# D!+# #"!(%&(! >#( $ I*& >$"&(' "<' $ >'( ) D!%#I!) "#+!D*(! ?, ' )#<*&C >$"&(' "<*(!& %? $ G ) D!%#I!) "#+!D*(! ?

59

= 45. ' L % $ + & "

' L % $ ' + " + & "

- -= &"’$& &= ' + & & L =,

L# (%&! #(.ET&C%?

?)$ "#+!D – B' "#+!D , D)$%& ?+ F )!T

#" #D !A H D(’?D#+ D G*+! ) !+), I $D

D)$%&* "#+!D* )#<. (# D #I & T" H ( % #(#+

> # !?( $%&C !I# ($"%*& $%&C !+&*, ?+ H (F#" &C

"# > '")'&* "#+!D*(! ? ># %> !($

'> ?)$ "#+!D – B' "#+!D , ?+$ )!E&C I!=!D !A H

D(’?D#+ D G*+! ) !+), I D D)$%&* "#+!D*

)#<. (# D #I & "'+$.C+! ( $( $H )$ $ $)#($ F

( % #(+$( > # !?( $%&C !I# ($"%*& $%&C !+&$(,

?+$ )!E&C D !A' ? ".? %> !(

Q! > #B'%#) # )*(! ? ($"#)#%&'H > # !+&

' ($% $ – B' "#+!D , ?+$ % # )#(! $ * > #B'%$

I'D>#%' '" C#=# (>. (* G*+! #=# !+&*

(>#"$,, "$,, ?( L!) ! "<' '.# "#+!D*, D ?+#=#

D=#"#) > #D=.?"$ %> !( I*"' #& )! !

$ # )!B$? > # B'H !+&

#F$" $ – B' "#+!D , ?+$ ($"#I !<!E&C ($"#)#%&$,

#& )! $ $D $ G F "<' '.

Q! "<' '.#) # )*(! ?

%#I %&$ "#+!D – B' "#+!D , ?+$ ( F#"?&C ($"$D A F #%$I, L# #" #A!% # T "<' '.!) %($"A' C > # !+&

'A#($ "#+!D – B' #I’T+& '< (#, > #" , ?+$'%*&C %.$" , ($"I &+ >#"$H, ?( L, "$H, !?( $%&C !I# ($"%*& $%&C ?+ F (%&! #(.ET&C%? ( > #B'%$ "#+!D*(! ?

60