Slyschenkov_V_A_Dogovor_K-P_i_perekhod_prava_sobstvennosti_sravnitelno-pravovoe_issledovanie
.pdf(sale) ,
,
(acknowledge) , ;
" ( acknowledge
attorn, ,
) ( .: Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 41. Para 170, fn. 6).
. . 24, 25 (1) 1979 .
" <1>
.,
, , "
" <2>. . 1 (4)
1889 .: " " " (document of title) (bill of lading), (dock warrant), (warehouse-keeper's certificate),
, ,
, ,
,
, (represented)". .. 24, 25 (1) 1979 . ,
. , ,
, ,
, ,
<3>. ,
, , . 25 (1)
1979 .
, <4>.
( .
).
--------------------------------
<1> 61 (1) 1979 .
,
1889 . ( , ,
. 29 (4) 1979 ., .
, )
.: Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 41. Para 170, fn. 8).
<2> .: Halsbury's Laws. Vol. 41. Para 157, fn. 9. <3> Ibid. Para 157, fn. 10.
<4> Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 981 - 982.
,
(constructive), :
(constructive) .
, -
,
(delivery by attornment)
.
. , ,
(attorn)
(bailee) . ,
, .
,
.
" <1>. ,
brevi manu
" " (constructive delivery) <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> . : Forsythe International (UK) v Silver Shipping Co and Petroglobe International (The Saetta) [1994] 1 All ER 851, 863.
<2> constructive possession.
, ,
(delivery order)
, <1>.
(bailee) , -
. 1 (2) 1889 .
,
<2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 121; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 972 - 973.
<2> .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 354, 975.
,
,
. . 24, 25 (1) 1979 .? Gamer's Motor Centre (Newcastle) Pty Ltd v Natwest Wholesale Australia Pty Ltd <1> -
,
. -
,
) .
;
, ,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
(bailee) .
, .
, (constructive delivery)
,
.
--------------------------------
<1> (1987) 163 CLR 236.
. . 24, 25 (1)
1979 .,
? Nicholson v Harper <1>. , ,
, .
, , ,
. 25 (1) 1893 . <2>,
, ( )
. ,
, . 25 (1) 1893 . , <3>.
. 25 (1) 1893 .
, (
). ,
,
<4>; ,
, ,
<5>.
--------------------------------
<1> [1895] 2 Ch 415.
<2> , . 24 1979 . <3> [1895] 2 Ch 415, 418.
<4> . Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 332:
, ,
" "
- ,
,
Nicholson v Harper .
<5> Ibid.
Archivent Sales and Development Ltd v Strathclyde Regional Council <1> ,
) ,
( )
.
. 25 (1) 1979 . - , ,
.
--------------------------------
<1> (1984) 27 Build LR 98.
* * *
,
. . 24, 25 (1) 1979 . <1>. ,
,
.
.
,
.
,
nemo dat quod non habet.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Miles. R. Op. cit. P. 192.
nemo dat.
,
( . . 24, 25 (1) 1979 .),
<1>.
nemo dat : (estoppel),
(mercantile agent)
, (hire-purchase).
--------------------------------
<1> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 368 - 414; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 289 - 346.
Lickbarrow v Mason, : " ,
,
,
" <1>.
1979 ., - 1893 . <2>. 21 (1) 1979 .,
nemo dat, , ,
, ,
" (unless the owner of the goods is by his conduct precluded from denying the seller's authority to sell). , .
,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
"
" (the apparent ownership or the right to sell) <3>,
.
,
, .
(representation),
, ,
, ; (negligence)
,
<4>. ,
(estoppel by representation) ,
, ,
(
, ) <5>.
,
(erga omnes), (
" " ) <6>.
( )
,
,
<7>.
--------------------------------
<1> (1787) 2 T.R. 63; . : Miles R. Op. cit. P. 197 - 198.
<2> .: Miles R. Op. cit. P. 197 - 201; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 292 - 300; Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 371 - 381.
<3> .: Eastern Distributors Ltd. v Goldring [1957] 2 Q.B. 600, 610.
<4> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 373 - 380; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 293 - 300.
<5> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 374; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 293 - 296.
<6> .: Eastern Distributors Ltd. v Goldring [1957] 2 Q.B. 600, 606 - 607, 611; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 293.
<7> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 395.
(mercantile agent)
. 2 (1) 1889 . <1>.
: ,
, ,
, . (disposition) <2>.
.
, . . 24 25 (1) 1979 . . 2
1889 . ,
<3>.
--------------------------------
<1> " , ,
, (sale),
(pledge) (disposition) ,
(in the ordinary course of business) , ,
, , (expressly)
; , ,
,
, , ,
".
<2> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 384 - 385, 388, 395 - 396; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 310 - 311, 313 - 314.
<3> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 395.
27 (2) (hire-purchase) 1964 .
" " (private purchaser) <1>
( ) (
<2>)
<3>. . 27 (2)
<4>.
--------------------------------
<1> , ( .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 409; Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 338;
. 29 (2) 1964 .).
<2> (conditional sale agreement)
,
, ( .
(Consumer Credit Act) 1974 ., . 189 (1)). <3> 27 (1), (2) 1964 .: "(1)
,
(bailed) ( )
,
(disposes) . (2)
, , (1) ,
,
, ,
".
<4> 27 (2)
nemo dat,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
, ,
( .: Benjamin's Sale of Goods. P. 337).
5.2.2. ,
,
, , ,
, ,
. :
,
.
"
" (privity of contract). . : "
, -
, , ,
, " <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 580.
, ,
,
. -
( ),
,
, .
. , ,
,
. ,
, .
The Stena Nautica (N 2) <1>.
(Stena Nautica) ( )
. ,
,
, Stena Nautica
.
,
.
.
,
, .
. ,
.
. ,
. 52 1979 . , ,
,
. , , ,
, ,
. . : "
[ ]
,
(actual knowledge)..." <2>.
--------------------------------
<1> [1982] 2 Lloyd's Rep. 336.
<2> Treitel G. The Law of Contract. P. 624 - 625.
Port Line, Ltd. v Ben Line Steamers, Ltd. <1>
<2>
,
.
, .
.
, (
) :
) .
, ,
) . , ,
, " .
" <3>. , ,
<4>. , ,
, ,
, ,
,
( .
) .
--------------------------------
<1> [1958] Q.B. 146.
<2> (time charter)
., ( ).
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
.
<3> Port Line, Ltd. v Ben Line Steamers, Ltd. [1958] Q.B. 146, P. 166.
, Lord Strathcona Steamship Co Ltd v Dominion Coal Co Ltd [1926] Ac 108, ,
.: Anson's Law of contract. P. 459). <4> .: Treitel G. The law of contract. P. 624.
,
. , ,
<1>. ,
. ,
.
<2>, ,
;
,
<3>.
, "
" ( . 12 (2) (b) 1979 .).
,
.
--------------------------------
<1> Ibidem; Anson's Law of Contract. P. 460; De Mattos v Gibson [1843 - 1860] All ER Rep 803.
<2> .: Anson's Law of Contract. P. 460. <3> Anson's Law of Contract. P. 460.
.
. , ,
, ,
<1>. ,
,
, ,
. ,
, ,
<2>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Daniels v Davison [1803 - 1813] All ER Rep 432; Smith v Jones [1954] 2 All ER 823.
<2> Williams & Glyn's Bank v Boland [1981] AC 487; Midland Bank Limited v Farmpride Hatcheries Limited and Another [1981] EGD 985; Land Registration Act 2002 ( . . 29, 30, schedule 3); . : Gray K. Gray S.F. Op. cit. P. 1232 - 1236.
,
, .
,
.
5.2.3. :
nemo dat, . . 24, 25
1979 .,
,
, . 18 (1) 1979 .
,
, .
.
,
nemo dat, , (
, )
<1>. ,
,
" " (ostensible) <2>.
; ,
,
<3>. ,
nemo dat .
nemo dat,
,
, ,
( . 25 (1) 1979 .).
. :
,
. 27 (2) 1964 . ("
,
"),
, .
--------------------------------
<1> .: Atiyah P.S., Adams J.N., Macqueen G. Op. cit. P. 395 <2> .: Anson's Law of Contract. P. 667, 673.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )