Slyschenkov_V_A_Dogovor_K-P_i_perekhod_prava_sobstvennosti_sravnitelno-pravovoe_issledovanie
.pdf( .
); ,
, , ,
(
, , -
). ,
, "
". . : . . . . 138; Gordley J. Op. cit. P. 32 - 33. " " ( " ")
,
, " "
.
" "
,
, , )
. . .
,
: . :
. . 13 - 14; . : .
( . "
") //
. 2007. N 1. ., 2008. . 631 - 647.
,
.
.
,
( ),
<1>.
, .
( . , ,
).
--------------------------------
<1> .: . . . . 76 - 84.
(tertium comparationis), ,
, -
<1>.
, , ,
.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Jansen N. Comparative Law and Comparative Knowledge // The Oxford Handbook on Comparative Law / Ed. by M. Reimann, R. Zimmermann. Oxford, 2006. P. 310 - 315.
,
<1>.
--------------------------------
<1> ,
.: .
: . . 10, 19, 23.
, ,
;
<1>. ,
, ,
( ) : "
, ,
,
,
, " <2>.
. "
" <3>,
.
--------------------------------
<1> . . ( .
.) . .
( .: .
. ., 2007. . 17 - 23).
<2> ., . . . . 1. . 58 - 59. <3> . . 50.
, ,
: 1)
<1>; 2)
- ,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
<2>; 3)
<3>; 4)
,
<4>, , <5>; 5) ( . .
<6>)
<7> <8>; 6)
,
<9>; 7)
,
<10>,
,
, <11>.
--------------------------------
<1> Hill J. Comparative Law, Law Reform and Legal Theory // Oxford Journal of Legal Studies. 1989. N 9. P. 104: "
,
. ,
,
, " ",
, ,
, "; . :
. . 17: "
. " " , ,
,
(
), , .
, ,
- ,
".
<2> Michaels R. The Functional Method of Comparative Law // The Oxford Handbook on Comparative Law / Ed. by M. Reimann, R. Zimmermann. Oxford, 2006. P. 375: "[ ]
. ,
,
"; "
,
";
, , ,
.
<3> Hill J. Op. cit. P. 106 - 107: " [ ]
. , ,
,
. ,
, , - , -
. - , ,
, .
:
?".
<4>
,
.
<5> .: Michaels R. Op. cit. P. 353 - 353 ( . ). <6> ., . . . . 1. . 40: "
.
- , ,
".
<7>
.: . : . . 12 - 14.
<8> . (Op. cit. P. 349) "
".
<9> . . ( . . . 1. . 59)
, "
". . ( : . . 16) : "
: ,
, ,
.
.
. " (
. - .).
, ,
,
, - . " ,
,
,
.
" " ( .,
. . . . 1. . 58).
,
, " ".
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
- , .
( . (similarity)
( .: Michaels R. Op. cit. P. 371)),
(
, , ).
,
( . N 2 ).
<10> .: Hill J. Op. cit. P. 111 - 113.
. . ,
( . . . 2).
<11> .: Michaels R. Op. cit. P. 380.
,
.
.
(tertium comparationis),
.
,
,
.
.
,
;
,
. . : "
,
,
( . . - .).
, ,
. ,
(shared beliefs) (ultimate values) , ,
, .
Volksgeist ( . - .),
.
,
,
" <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> Cotterrell R. Comparative Law and Legal Culture // The Oxford Handbook on Comparative Law / Ed. by M. Reimann, R. Zimmermann. Oxford, 2006. P. 733 - 734.
,
(
), . ,
- . <1>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: Legrand P. The Same and the Different // Comparative Legal Studies: Traditions and Transitions / Ed. by P. Legrand, R. Munday. Cambridge, 2003.
,
,
. ,
,
, . ,
. , ( ,
, ), -
-
.
,
.
,
,
.
,
, .
.
,
, ,
,
(
).
* * *
.
.
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
. ,
,
.
.
. ,
-
, .
;
.
, , :
, ,
)
,
.
.
, ,
. ,
.
.
,
-
,
.
,
.
, , ,
2010 .
1. :
<1>.
.
XVII .,
1649 . <2>.
I
. ,
. 30- . XIX .
,
<3>. , 1 1835 .
<4>. ( . 10, . 1)
, 15 <5>.
<6>;
( , <7>)
. ,
,
<8>.
, Corpus Iuris Civilis,
<9>.
<10>,
1917 . <11>.
--------------------------------
<1> .: .
( , 16 1894 .). , 1894.. 6; . : .
XIX - XX . // . 2000. N 1 (6).. 194 - 202; ., .
// . 1996. N 1. . 9 - 14; .:
. . ., 2008.
<2> .: . . 6 - 9; . : .
. ., 1998. . 55.
<3> .: . . . . 55; . :
. ,
II .
., 1837. . 12 - 41 ( 10 ). <4> - .
<5> 1830 .
,
1649 . 12 1825 .), ,
(
) ( .: ( . . . X. . I).
/ . . , .
. ., 1913. . 1. . 4. . : .
// ,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )
. . , . ., 1858. . II. . 2 - 3). 1892 .
XVI ( .: . .
., 1914. . 331).
<6> , ,
, ,
( .: . . ., 1905. . 65 - 66, 73 - 101).
<7> , , II
( 1826 .), ,
II 1882 .,
( 1894 . - , 1906 . -
).
( (1844 .) (1860.) , 1887 . - , 1900 . - ,
1914 . - ),
.
II ( )
, ,
, " ",
, . .:
( . . . X. . I).
. . 4 - 5, 9 - 11.
<8> .: . . . . 320.
<9> .: . . 104. <10> . . . . 46 - 72, 129 - 144.
<11> ( ).: //
:
, ,
1922 , 1964 .
, 2003. . 37 - 320. .: . . 26 - 20.
, (
)
. .
: " ,
176 ,
, ,
, , ,
, " <1>. ,
<2>. ,
, .
,
, <3>.
--------------------------------
<1> . . . . 3. .
, :
;
,
" ( . . 2). , . ,
,
, (
), ,
. . : .
// . 1904. N 3. . 60 - 67.
<2> , ,
.
, .
, :
(bona corporalia et incorporalia),
,
, dominium, res extra commercium, res nullius usus,
(traditio), usucapio praescriptio . .:
. . . . 7 . . : .
. . 13 - 14; .
X // . 1895. N 8; . . ., 1908. . 1 . . ,
( . . . 67),
( . 75 .). <3> .: Ihering R. Geist des romischen Rechts auf den verschiedenen Stufen
seiner Entwicklung. Bd. 1. Leipzig, 1907. S. 41, fn. 14.
<1>.
:
, ,
. <2>;
.
--------------------------------
<1>
: " ,
,
: PRESSI ( HERSON )