For & Against by L G Alexander

The argument: key words

I 'Avoid rush-hour': slogan of every large city; no one does.

2Happens twice a day.

3Trains packed; streets crowded; bus queues; traffic jams; buses full.

4Commuting stretches man's resources.

5Unforeseen events (e.g, power-cut, heavy snowfall): chaos.

6People actually choose such conditions.

7Large modem cities too big to control.

8Impose their own living conditions on people.

9City-dwellers: unnatural way of life.

10	Lose touch with land, rhythms of nature.
I I	Air-conditioned existence: barely conscious of seasons: flowers:
	spring; leaves: autumn; nature irrelevant.

12Simple good things (e.g, sunlight, fresh air) at a premium.

13Distinction day, night is lost; always noise, traffic.

14Expensive 'privilege'.

15Accommodation: house of your own impossible; rents high.

16Cost of living in general high.

17Lack of security: cities breed crime and violence; houses often burgled.

18Cities not fit to live in; man born for country.

The counter-argument: key words

I If proposition is true, then there are millions of madmen.

2Most people love cities: proof: man is fleeing from countryside.

3Modem man too sophisticated for simple country pleasures.

4It's enough to visit countryside at week-ends.

5Objections to city living are unconvincing:

6Commuting does not really affect those who live in cities; a small inconvenience only.

7Noise, traffic, etc., hardly noticeable; people easily adapt.

8Very small minority of city-dwellers ever involved in crime, violence.

9Many reasons why city life is preferable:

10	Good to be near one's friends; never cut off by weather conditions.
I I	Life is never dull; always something to do.

12Cities offer high concentration of good things in life: big stores, restaurants, theatres, cinemas, galleries, etc.

13Services are always better: better schools, more amenities (e.g, swimming-pools, etc.).

14More chances of employment; greater range of jobs; more opportunity to succeed in life.

53