Добавил:
Опубликованный материал нарушает ваши авторские права? Сообщите нам.
Вуз: Предмет: Файл:

Thompson Work Organisations A Critical Introduction (3rd ed)

.pdf
Скачиваний:
470
Добавлен:
22.08.2013
Размер:
14.69 Mб
Скачать

Work Organisations

A Critical Introduction

Work Organisations

A Critical Introduction

Third edition

Paul Thompson

and

David McHugh

© Paul Thompson and David McHugh 1990, 1995, 2002

All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission.

No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP.

Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosection and civil claims for damages.

The authors have asserted their rights to be identified as the authors of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988.

First edition 1990

Reprinted 5 times

Second edition 1995

Reprinted 7 times

Third edition 2002

Published by PALGRAVE

Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N. Y. 10010

Companies and representatives throughout the world

PALGRAVE is the new global academic imprint of

St. Martin’s Press LLC Scholarly and Reference Division and Palgrave Publishers Ltd (formerly Macmillan Press Ltd).

ISBN 0–333–94991–9 paperback

ISBN 0–333–98095–9 hardcover

This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest souces.

A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.

10

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

11

10

09

08

07

06

05

04

03

02

Printed in Great Britain by

Anthony Rowe Ltd

Chippenham, Wiltshire

Contents

List of tables and figures

xi

Acknowledgements

xii

Introduction

xiii

Part I

 

1 Studying organisations: an introduction

3

Organisations and organisation society

3

Defining the scope and purpose of organisations

5

Organisational analysis: problems and problematics

7

Goals, diversity and interests

8

Rationality, efficiency and choice

10

Hierarchy and the division of labour

12

Management and managerialism

12

A science of organisations?

14

A concluding comment

14

An alternative and critical agenda

15

Reflexivity

15

The embeddedness of organisations

16

Multi-dimensionality

16

Structure, contradiction and agency

17

Social transformation and change

18

Conclusion

19

2 The emergence of large-scale organisations

20

Organising the new work forms

20

The rise of the factory system

21

Modes of control in the transition to bureaucratic organisation

23

Decay and decline of traditional controls

25

Conclusion

28

3 Taylor, Weber and the bureaucratisation of the workplace

29

Taylorism and systematic management

29

Principles

30

Ideology and practice

31

Weber and administrative theories of management

34

The rise of bureaucratic control and its contradictions

38

Scientific management and bureaucratic work rules: modern legacies

40

Conclusion

41

4 Managing the human factor

42

Social science and industry: a courtship

42

vi • CO N T E N T S

 

Hawthorne and beyond

45

 

Consolidating human relations

49

 

Legacies and continuities: from human relations to human

 

 

resource management

51

 

Conclusion

53

5

Organisations and environments

54

 

Closed systems?

55

 

Adaptation to the environment: open system approaches

56

 

Contingency theory

58

 

Selection theories: the population ecology approach

61

 

Critique and alternatives

63

 

Enacted environments?

66

 

Conclusion

69

6

Capital, labour and the state in a globalising era

70

 

Comparative analysis: beyond the American model

70

 

The rise of cultural explanations

71

 

Institutional theories

76

 

Globalisation

79

 

Understanding the comparative influences on work organisation

82

 

The state still matters

85

 

Conclusion

86

7

Management

87

 

Classical management theory

87

 

The nature of management

89

 

Management practices: a new realism?

91

 

Bringing the threads together: management as a labour process

94

 

Armstrong and inter-professional competition

96

 

Conclusion

100

8

Control: concepts and strategies

101

 

Mainstream mis/understandings

101

 

Radical perspectives: labour process theories of control

103

 

Management strategies

105

 

Questioning strategy

109

 

Questioning control over labour

111

 

New directions? Surveillance and shifting the locus of control

113

 

Conclusion

116

9

Power, conflict and resistance

117

 

Power in mainstream theory

117

 

Mainstream models

119

 

A critical evaluation: three-dimensional analyses

121

 

Foucault, post-structuralism and disciplinary power

124

 

Applications to organisations

126

 

Critique

128

 

Conclusion

131

10

Gender, sexuality and organisations

132

 

Policy parameters and intellectual frameworks

132

CO N T E N T S • v i i

Gendering organisational analysis

134

Kanter and organisational context

134

Theorising difference

136

Culture, careers and networks: embedding gender

139

Enter sexuality

140

Contrasting perspectives on sex, power and organisations

142

Evaluation: under and overpowered explanations

144

From equal opportunity to managing diversity?

145

Conclusion

147

11 New Economy, new organisations?

149

Introduction: paradigm shift or shifting paradigms?

149

Firms, markets and hierarchies in the knowledge economy

150

Post-bureaucratic organisation: restructuring the corporation

154

Flexibility, work and employment

156

Japanese production regimes

157

The flexible firm model

158

Home and teleworking

161

Knowledge work and portfolio people

161

High performance and work systems: restructuring the division of labour

163

Conclusion

165

12 Continuity and change at work

167

Hierarchies, networks and knowledge revisited

167

Knowledge in the economy

169

Corporate structures: organised capitalism

172

A new flexible firm?

175

Changing employment relations and the new insecurity

178

Participation, control and commitment in the labour process

180

Autonomy, control and surveillance

181

Skills, tasks and rules

184

The effort bargain and work intensification

188

Conclusion

189

13 Corporations and culture: reinventing organisation man?

191

Product and perspective: the corporate culture merchants

193

HRM and the management of culture

195

Critics and questions

197

Questioning the novelty

197

Questioning the evidence

198

Questioning the concepts

200

Culture: commitment or control?

202

The limits to cultural influence

204

Conclusion

208

Part II

 

14 Understanding organisational behaviour: issues and agendas

213

Technologies of regulation?

213

Topics and texts: subjects and subjectivities

217

Defining the ‘subjective factor’

218

Conclusion

221

viii • CO N T E N T S

15 Masks for tasks: perception, attitudes and personality

222

Perception: learning what to see

222

Perceptual processing

222

Perceptual categorisation

224

Attribution theory

226

The attitude problem

229

Defining attitudes

229

Attitudes and behaviour

230

Attitude change

231

Personality: masks for tasks

233

Types, traits and tests

234

Personality and selection

235

Conclusion

238

16 Learning, change and innovation

240

Learning and socialisation: seeing what to do

240

Socialisation

243

Roles

244

Skills and styles

245

Learning and development

246

Learning organisations

247

Organisational learning versus learning organisations

247

Changing the people?

249

Models and processes

250

Change and stability

252

Innovation: necessity or luxury?

253

Defining innovation

253

Diffusing innovation: change agents and agencies

254

Climate and culture

254

Sustaining innovation

255

Creativity

255

Social and organisational creativity

257

Conclusion: creativity, learning and sustaining innovation

258

17 Open to persuasion: communication and leadership

260

The power to communicate

260

Interpersonal influence

264

Leadership, might or myth?

266

Traits and characteristics

267

Styles and roles

268

Contingent leadership

269

Transforming leadership

271

Charisma?

272

Networking

274

Attributing leadership

275

Conclusion

276

18 Putting the pressure on: stress, work and emotion

277

Stress: the force to adapt

277

Role stress

280

Stress management

281

Stress counselling

283

CO N T E N T S • i x

Employee assistance programmes

283

Contesting stress

285

Emotional labour

286

Emotion management

287

Stress and control

289

Role socialisation and control

290

Stress in the labour process

292

Conclusion

293

19 Motivation: the drive for satisfaction

294

Motivation or motivating?

294

Enriching the content

295

Content theories

296

The drive for satisfaction

297

The ‘kick in the ass’ life cycle

300

Process theories

301

The goals of motivation

303

Goal-setting

304

Goals versus identity projects

305

Motivation as an artefact

306

Control theories

307

Self-concept theory

308

Control, self-concepts and identity

310

Mobilising commitment

310

Internalisation of commitment

312

Institutional commitment?

313

Conclusion

314

20 From groups to teams

316

The authority of the group

316

Group formation and composition

317

Group socialisation

319

Group cohesiveness and polarisation

320

Group responses to pressures on identity

321

Group resistance and conflict

323

Teamworking

324

Re-engaging the worker

325

Team dimensions

327

Groups versus teams

329

Conclusion

332

21 Identity work

334

Explanations of identity

334

Redefining the agenda

336

Gender and ethnic identities

337

Domination and security

338

Organisations and identities

339

Identity work and situational power

339

Responses to pressures on identity

341

Impression management and scripting

343

Identity work and ‘making out’

346

Identity working: strategies for organisational survival

347