18-10-2014_18-18-15 / rome-club

2

()2">#' = ;$4"=$;$12"- 9%'2*)2$ ($ ./4" ) #'&$ ($ 9%$#9"4'>'4"1B. L 1$-;'1, = 1"=%$,$((", ".?$1*=$, ".15$()$ *'2)A C5(#',$(*'4B(/A 9$%$,$( ),$4" ./ ,'4" 1,/14', $14) ./ ,/ ./4) 5.$$(/, ;*" (/($G()$ *$,9/ ();$, ($ ">%'();$((">" %"1*' ,"&(" .5#$* =/#$%&'*B = .5#5?$,. H" =1$ #"2':'*$4B1*=',

),$<?)$18 = ('G$, %'19"%8&$()), >"="%8* " *",, ;*" ): *%$A '4B*$%('*)= – ($">%'();$((">" %"1*', #".%"="4B(">" ">%'();$()8 ) =/A"#' 2 $1*$1*=$((/, 9%$#$4', %"1*' – (' 1',", #$4$ %$'4B(/ *"4B2" #=$ 9"14$#()$.7

I14) ('G' 7$4B – 1"A%'()*B %'=("=$1)$ 1)1*$,/ (' #"4>"$ =%$,8 ) #".)*B18 5=$4);$()8 9%"#"4&)*$4B("1*) &):() , ,"&(" 9$%$;)14)*B ,)(),'4B(/- ('."% 514"=)- >4".'4B(">" %'=("=$1)8.

1. T.P$, 2'9)*'4' ) ;)14$(("1*B ('1$4$()8 "1*'<*18 9"1*"8((/,);

*$,9/ %"'$,"1*) ) 1,$%*("1*) %'=(/, 2'2 ) *$,9/ 2'9)*'4"=4"&$()- )

',"%*):'7)).

2. @1$ (';'4B(/$ ) 2"($;(/$ :(';$()8 – %"'$,"1*), 1,$%*("1*),

2'9)*'4"=4"&$()- ) ',"%*):'7)) 2'9)*'4' ,)(),'4B(/.

3 . V%"=() , (' 2"*"%/A 1*'.)4):)%5<*18 2'9)*'4 ) ;)14$(("1*B ('1$4$()8, ) 1""*("G$()$ ,$ 6*),) 5%"=(8,) 51*'('=4)='$* ".?$1*=" 1">4'1(" 1="), 9"*%$.("1*8,; 2">#' *$A();$12)- 9%">%$11 "*2%"$* ("=/$ =":,"&("1*), 6*) 5%"=() ,"&(" 1="."#(" ):,$(8*B ) "1*"%"&(" %$>54)%"='*B.

+'2"$ %'=("=$1)$ ($ ":(';'$* :'1*"8. @ 9%$#$4'A 9$%=/A #=5A 514"=)- 2"%9"%'7)) ,">5* %'1G)%8*B )4) 1="%';)='*B 1="< #$8*$4B("1*B, ('1$4$()$ 1*%'(/ )4) %$>)"(' ,"&$* %'1*) )4) 5,$(BG'*B18 , #"A"#/ ,">5* %'19%$#$48*B18 ."4$$ )4) ,$($$ %'=(",$%(". +$A();$12)- 9%">%$11 9":="4)* 9"1*$9$((" %'1G)%8*B 1C$%5 5145> , ".$19$;$((5< 9"1*"8((/, C"(#",

7	I#+,#(N R. =) 3.#$#()5& .-+,). A.: I.-6.#++, 1988, 9. 242–263

2

2'9)*'4'. @ 9%$#$4'A *%$*B$>" 514"=)8 4<.'8 1*%'(' ,"&$* ):,$()*B 1%$#()- 5%"=$(B &):(), 1.'4'(1)%"='= ;)14$(("1*B ('1$4$()8 ) ".P$, 2'9)*'4' (' #%5>", 5%"=($. 3%",$ *">", ".?$1*=" ,"&$* %$>54)%"='*B #$-1*=)$ =(5*%$(()A ) =($G()A C'2*"%"= ,$#4$((", 9"# 2"(*%"4$,, 9",(8 " (',$;$((/A 7$48A,

1()&'8 )4) 5=$4);)='8 ".P$, 2'9)*'4' ) ;)14$(("1*B ('1$4$()8 )4) ".$

=$4);)(/ =,$1*$ . +%) "9)1'((/A 514"=)8 #)(',);$12">" %'=("=$1)8 ($

9"*%$.5<*	) , =$%"8*(" , ($	1,">5* “ :',"%":)*B ”	1""*("G$()$ ,$
;)14$(("1*B< ('1$4$()8 ) ".P$,", 2'9)*'4' = ,)%$,			2'2 6*" 9%")1A"#)*
1$>"#(8. T() #"4&(/ #'*B 1="."#5 ,)%5, ) ($ 5#$%&)='*B $>" = 1,)%)*$4B("- 8
"D%$#$4/ %"1*'" J$#"5:/ (';)('<* 1 ):5;$()8 6219"($(7)'4B(">" %"1*'
('1$4$()8	(*.$. >$",$*%);$12)	9%">%$11)%5<?$>"). E=*"%/ 1;)*'<*, ;*"

;$4"=$;$1*=" %'1*$* 9" 6219"($(*$. @ 1970 >. ('1$4$()$ ,)%' 1"1*'=484" 3,6

,4%#. ;$4"=$2, ) 9%) %"1*$ 2,1% = >"# "(" #"4&(" 5#=")*B18 :' 33 >"#', ;*",

1".1*=$((", 1$>"#(8 ,/ ) ('.4<#'$, (('1$4$()$ ,)%' 9%$=/G'$* 5 ,4%#.

;$4"=$2). D" #'((/, ',$%)2'(12">" >$"4">' Z.!2)(($%' ('1$4$()$ ,)%' = 1982

>"#5 %"14" 1" 12"%"1*B< 1,7% = >"#, ;*" 9%)="#)* 2 5#="$()< ;$%$: 41 >"#. L $14) = 1982 >"#5 ;)14$(("1*B 4<#$- 1"1*'=484' 4,55 ,4%#., *" 2 2000 >"#5 ('1 "&)#'$*18 6 ,4%#.!3'2"- &$ =/="# 14$#5$* ): 9%">(":"=, 1#$4'((/A = 9%"$2*$ J$#"5:"=? Z/1*%/- %"1* ('1$4$()8 9%)=$#$* 2 ($A='*2$ %$15%1"= (2'2 9)?$=/A, *'2 ) 1/%B$=/A) . D%) 1"=%$,$((/A *$,9'A %"1*' )(#51*%)),

($=":".("=48$,/$ 9%)%"#(/$ %$15%1/ )1*"?'*18 ;$%$: 50-100 4$*. S'$*18 '('4): :'9'1"= ;$%(/A ) 7=$*(/A ,$*'44"=, ($C*), 5>48, 1%"2) )1*"?$()8 6*)A :'9'1"= ) #$4'<*18 1""*=$*1*=5<?)$ =/="#/ . @ 7$4", 6*) #'((/$ 9"#*=$%'<*18 Z.!2)($%", ("F='*)* 4) ;$4"=$;$1*=5 :$,(/A %$15%1"=?",

8	I#+,#(N R. =) 3.#$#()5& .-+,). A.: I.-6.#++, 1988, 9. 242–263

2

1 9 6 9 - 1 9 8 9 >>. ) .3"%";$ >"="%8, ,"#$4B %$15%1"= ,)%' – 6*" ,"#$4B

"5,$(BG'<?$>"18 9)%">'", "."1("='(('8, 21*'*) 12':'*B, $?$ #" J$#"5:"= – V"4*$%", 0.F'-..'%#",: "H" :'9'1/ ($".A"#),">" 1/%B8, 2"*"%/$ ,"&(" #"./*B ): ($#% ):=$1*(/,) ,$*"#',) 1 9%)$,4$,/,) :'*%'*',), ">%'();$(/, = *" =%$,8 2'2 *$,9/ )A 621945'*'7)) ) )19"4B:"='()8, ";$=)#(", ($*". ("J)($%'4B(/$ %$15%1/: =/:"= )4) 5>%":'?", 1968 >.).

3'2)$ ,$%/ 9%$#9"4'>'<*18 '=*"%',) "D%$#$4"=" #48 =/A"#' ): #'((">" 9"4"&$()8? @ 2';$1*=$ 1%$#1*= #48 9%$#"*=%'?$()8 .5#5?)A 2'*'1*%"C "() 9%$#4'>'<* )#$< "(54$=">" 9%)%"1*'": ($ #"4&(" ./*B %"1*' () 62"(",)2), () ('1$4$()8.

2.2. <%$6.#5 >.>6"*%$8&9*, ?.<6"#60' &, @*"*+* A(26.B*+*

@*"%"- #"24'# "0),12",5 345.5" ./4 ('9)1'( = 1974 >. 2"44$2*)=", '=*"%"= 9"# %52"="#1*=", ',$%)2'(12">" 2).$%($*)2' 9%"C. J.J$1'%"=);' ) #)%$2*"%' )(1*)*5*' *$"%$*);$12"- ,$A'()2) = U0Y X.D$1*$48.

@"*4);)$ "* " D%$#$4"= %"1*' " 9%"$2* J$1'%"=);' - D$1*$48 ($ 9%$#12':/='4 >4".'4B("- 2'*'1*%"C/ , =/:='(("- =/G$59",8(5*/,) 9%);)(',). T() 1;)*'4) ($):.$&(/,) #"="4B(" .4):2)$ 9" =%$,$() 1"./*)8 2'*'1*%"C);$12">" A'%'2*$%', (" = "*#$4B(/, %$>)"('A ,)%"="- 1)1*$,/. 9

@9%"G4",, 2'2 5*=$%'<* '=*"%/, =1$,)%("$ 1"".?$1*=" ./4" 9%"1*"- 1"="259("1*B< ($:'=)1),/A ;'1*$-. "@ ("=/A 514"=)8A =1$,)%("$ 1"".?$1*=" 1*'4" 9%$=%'?'*B18 =" =1$,)%(5< 1)1*$,5, *.$. = 1".%'()$ C5(27)"('4B(" =:'),"1=8:'((/A ;'1*$-. @ 2'"- *'2"- 1)1*$,$ %"1* "#("- 2'2"--4)." ;'1*)

9	R. I#+,#(N. =) 3.#$#()5& .-+,). A., 1988. , +. 149

2

:'=)1)* "* %"1*' )4) "*15*1*=)8 %"1*' #%5>)A ;'1*$-. T*1<#' – ($&$4'*$4B(/- %"1* "#("- ;'1*) 5>%"&'$* ($ *"4B2" 6*"- ;'1*), (" ) #%5>), ;'1*8,".

+'2), ".%':",, '=*"%',) 9%"$2*' ./4' 9%$#4"&$(' )#$8 ""%>'();$12">" #)CC$%$(7)%"='((">" %"1*'". J"#$4B =1$,)%(">" ,)%"=">" A":8-1*=' 9" J$1'%"=);5 ) D$1*$4< 1"1*")* ): 10 >$">%'C);$12)A %$>)"("=. @/#$48<*18 !$=$%('8 E,$%)2', O'9'#('8 I=%"9', R9"()8, #%5>)$ %':=)*/$ 2'91*%'(/,

1"7)'4)1*);$12)$ ) %':=)='<?)$18 1*%'(/. 3%",$ *">", =18 1)1*$,' =24<;'$* %':(/$ 5%"=() )$%'%A)). 3'/- 5%"=$(B, 1"1*"8?)- ): *">" )4) )(">" >"15#'%1*=' ()4) .4"2') ('A"#)*18 = 1"9"#;)($(("1*) "* #%5>)A 5%"=($-.

@/#$48<*18 1%$#/ )4) 1C$%/ ".)*'()8 ;$4"=$2' (24),'*);$12)$ 514"=)8,

="#/, :$,48, 62"4">);$12)$ 9%"7$11/); *$A("-1C$%' (A),);$12)$ ) C):);$12)$ 9%"7$11/ ) ; #$,">%'C);$12'8 , 62"(",);$12'8 , ".?$1*=$(('8 1C$%/ ;

)(#)=)#5'4B('8 (91)A"4">);$12)- ) .)"4">);$12)- ,)% ;$4"=$2'). @24<;$()$ 6*)A 1C$% (' %':(/A 5%"=(8A = )$%'%A);$125< 1)1*$,5 #"4&(" 9":="4)*B, 9" ,($()< '=*"%"=, 9%">(":)%"='*B )A 1"1*"8()$.

H" %'115$()8 " =:'),":'=)1),"1*) %$>)"("= ) ($&$4'*$4B("1*) %"1*' ($2"*"%/A ): ()A #"="4B(" ($9%)2%/*" =/%'&'<* )(*$%$1/ 9%$$ =1$>" *$A 1*%'(, 2"*"%/$ :'(),'<* "=/1G)$ 5%"=()" = )$%'%A)) ,"#$4) J$1'%"=);'-

D$1*$48. D" 15*) #$4', %8#5 1*%'( ) %$>)"("= 9"#%':5,$='4"1B ('=8:/='()$ 9"4)*)2) :'1*"8 62"(",)2) )4) *$A("4">);$12'8 ,"#$%():'7)8 1 ".8:'*$4B(/, 514"=)$, 4).$%'4):'7)) 9"4)*);$12"- 1)1*$,/. 3 *",5 &$, *$A("4">);$12'8 :'=)1),"1*B (' "(' ($):.$&(') "#()A 1*%'( "* #%5>)A, 8=48$*18 '1),,$*%);("- C"%,"- "*("G$()-, 51)4)='<?)A 9"#;)($(("1*B. J"#$%():'7)8 &$ 62"(",)2),

9"#%':5,$='$,'8 ) 2'2 =($#%$()$ 4).$%'4B(/A 9%)"%)*$*"= = ".?$1*=$((5< ) 9"4)*);$125< &):(B 1*%'( ():G)A ) 1%$#()A 5%"=($-, 9%)="#)*, = 1="< ";$%$#B, 2 5()C)2'7)) =1$A 1"7)"-254B*5%(/A 64$,$(*"= ":'=)1),"-" 1*%'(/

2

9" "',$%)2'(12",5 ".%':75". X*) :'2',5C4)%"='((/$ ('5;("- *$%,)("4">)$- ) %'115$()8,) " ,$('%"#(", 1"*%5#();$1*=$ 95(2*/ 9%"$2*' 1$>"#(8 1*'("=8*18 %$'4)8,) (%'19'# @"1*";(">" .4"2', !!!0 ) *.9. 9"4)*)2' = "*("G$()) "2"(*)($(*'4B(/A 1*%'( I=%':))").

3"(2%$*(/- 9%"$2* 9%$#4"&)4 (', F'1'( T:.$2A'( - *5%"2 9" 9%")1A"$()<, 5;$(/--2).$%($*)2, 19$7)'4)1* 9" 94'()%"='()< ) C)4"1"C,

=":>4'=48=G)- = *" =%$,8 "#)( ): 2'4)C"%()-12)A ,":>"=/A *%$1*"=. R 14/G'4 ,(">" 4$1*(">" ". 6*", ;$4"=$2$, = 2"*"%", >45."2'8 254B*5%' 1";$*'4'1B 1

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

%$:54B*'*/ 2"*"%/A *%5#(" ./4" 9%$#5>'#'*B :'%'($$. H$1,"*%8 (' 6*",

T:.$2A'( ./4 '.1"4<*(" 5=$%$(, ;*" 9"14$#5<?$$ %':=)*)$ 6*"- ,$*"#)2) #'1* (', = 2"(7$ 2"(7"= ),$((" *", ;*" ./4" (', (5&(", - 19"1".("1*B #"A"#;)=" ) 5.$#)*$4B(" 9%"#$,"(1*%)%"='*B ,("&$1*=5 1',/A %':(/A 4<#$- 15*B (/($G($- 1)*5'7)) = ,)%$.10

10	R. I#+,#(N. =) 3.#$#()5& .-+,). A., 1988., 127

2

2.3. <%$6.#5 3.C*+ & "3%')1D&6 200 06#"?.E*"0$ $ ;60'B 960$8696"#8*

Y5#:"("=12)- )(1*)*5* =" >4'=$ 1 ):=$1*(/, C5*5%"4">", Y.3'(", %':%'."*'4 #"4>"1%";(/- 9%">(":: "Y%8#5?)$ 200. !7$('%)- #48 E,$%)2) ) #48 ,)%'" (1976), #'*' 2"*"%">" ./4' 1=8:'(' 1 9%':#("='()$, #=5A1"*4$*)8 !KE.

@ "*4);)$ "* :'?)*()2"= " (54$=">" 9%)%"1*' " , 9%$#1*'=)*$4) Y5#:"("=12">" )(1*)*5*', ('"."%"*, 1;)*'4), ;*" ;$4"=$;$12"$ ".?$1*=" .5#$* %':=)='*B18 #"1*'*";(" )(*$(1)=(": "(' ('G$- 94'($*$ #"1*'*";(" 9%"1*%'(1*=' ) %$15%1"= #48 *">", ;*"./ (' ($- ,">4) &)*B "* 15 #" 30 ,4%#. ;$4"=$2". S48

.$:.$#("- &):() *'2">" 2"4);$1*=' 4<#$- 14$#5$* %':=)='*B ('52) ) 1"=$%G$(1*="='*B *$A("4">)) . @1$ 6*" =":,"&(" = *'2 (':/='$,",

"9"1*)(#51*%)'4B(", ".?$1*=$" (9"(8*)$, 1$>"#(8 #"1*'*";(" :'*'12'(("$).

!C$%/ "9"1*)(#51*%)'4B(">" ".?$1*='" 3'(', =/#$48$,/$ ),, =/>48#8* 14$#5<?), ".%':", : 9$%=);('8 – 1$4B12"$ A":8-1*=" , 4$1();$1*=" ,

%/."4"=1*=" , >"%("#"./='<?'8 9%",/G4$(("1*B ; =*"%);('8 – ".%'.'*/='<?'8 9%",/G4$(("1*B , 1*%")*$4B1*=" ; *%$*);('8 – 5145>) ,

*%'(19"%*, C)('(1/, 59%'=4$()$ (,$($#&,$(*), ".%':"='()$. W$*=$%*);('8 1C$%', 9%">(":)%5$,'8 3'(",, 9%$#9"4'>'$* %)*5'4/, 61*$*)25, 1":#'()$ ("=/A *%'#)7)-, "./;'$=, %':=)*)$ )12511*= (%'#) )12511*='), *5%):,, )>%/, 9%':#(/- ".%': &):(). +" $1*B, 6*'2)- "254B*5%"4">);$12)- %'-", 5*"9):,.

S'(('8 %'."*' ="94"?'$* = 1$.$ 9" 15*) =1$ "1("=(/$ ('9%'=4$()8 C5*5%"4">);$12">" 9")12'. 3'( ($ 12%/='$*, ;*" = 2';$1*=$ *$"%$*);$12"- 9'%'#)>,/ ), =:8*' )#$8 "9"1*)(#51*%)'4B(">" ".?$1*='" = *", =)#$, = 2'2", "(' ('9)1'(' S.Z$44",. 3 *",5 &$, :#$1B C'2*);$12) 9$%$12':/='4"1B

2

1"#$%&'()$ #%5>"- %'."*/, ('9)1'(("- 3'(", = 1"'=*"%1*=$ 1 E.@)($%", –

"S=5A*/18;(/- >"#".

H$ 145;'$( ) =/."% #'*/ – *";2) "*1;$*' 9%">(":' – 9%"=":>4'G$()$ ($:'=)1),"1*) !KE. +$, 1',/, .$: ".)(82"= #'$*18 9"(8*B, ;*" 1"=%$,$(('8 )1*"%)8 ;$4"=$;$1*=' (';'4'1B *">#', 2">#' ',$%)2'(12)$ 2"4"()) .%"1)4) =/:"= .%)*'(12",5 =4'#/;$1*=5. ! 6*), &$ 1"./*)$, 1=8:/='$*18 ) (';'4" 9%",/G4$(("- %$="4<7)) , 9%$".%':)=G$- 4)7" ,)%' 1""*=$*1*=5<?), ".%':", ) #'=G$- %"$()$ ("=",5 *)95 ;$4"=$2' – *$A("2%'*5- 9"*%$.)*$4<.

T*1<#' ) =/="#, ;*" ;$*/%$A1"*4$*()- 9$%)"# (*.$. #=$1*) 4$* 15?$1*="='()8 !KE ) #=$1*) 4$* =9$%$#) ""2'&$*18 *'2), &$ #%','*);(/, = )1*"%)) ;$4"=$;$1*=', 2'2),) ./4) 9%$#G$1*="='=G)$ #$18*B */18; 4$*". D"#".('8 ,$%' "*1;$*' 8=(" 1"#$%&)* 9%$*$(:)< (' *", ;*" =1$ #'4B($-G$$ %':=)*)$ ;$4"=$;$1*=' .5#$* %'11,'*%)='*B18 *"4B2" 1 *";2) :%$()8 ',$%)2'(12"-,

*"4B2" = 2"(*$21*$ " ',$%)2'(12">" " ,)%' . " H"=/- L$%51'4), " ,

9%"=":>4'G$((/- S.@'G)(>*"(",, #"4&$( 1*'*B ".%':7", ) 6*'4"(", #48 =1$>"

"1*'%">" ,)%'". [)=5;$1*B 2"(7$97)) ) 12"%"1*B $$ ="94"?$()8 5#)=)*$4B(/:

9"2' "=1$ )#$* 9" 94'(5". @" =182", 145;'$, 2"(=$%>$(7)8 #=5A 1"7)'4B("-

62"(",);$12)A 1)1*$, (2'9)*'4)1*);$12"- ) 1"7)'4)1*);$12"-) 1*'("=)*18 ($&$4'*$4B("-, (", 5=/, – %$'4B("1*B<.

@ 7$4",, 2"(7$97)< 3'(' ,"&(" "A'%'2*$%):"='*B, 2'2 "2%'-()- *$A("4">);$12)- "9*),):,". @ "*4);)$ "* 9%$#G$1*=$(()2"= "( #"2':/='$* "G).";("1*B 9"#1;$*"= ,)($%'4B(/A %$15%1"= , "."1("=/='$* %$G$()$ 9%"#"="4B1*=$(("- ) 6($%>$*);$12"- 9%".4$, (= ;'1*("1*) – 9" $>" ,($()< =

90-A >"#'A =":,"&(" .5#$* )19"4B:"='*B 1)1*$,5 8#$%(">" 1)(*$:' +T3EJE3,

"1("='((5< (' 1"=$*12", ):".%$*$())). Z"4BG)$ ('#$/ =":4'>'<*18 ('

2

9%"):="#1*=" 1)(*$*);$12"- 9)?), "1("='(("$ (' 5*)4):'7)) "%>'();$12)A "*A"#"= %':(/A "*%'14$- 9%",/G4$(("1*).

@ 1977 >"#5 9"# %52"="#1*=", ',$%)2'(12">" 1"7)"4">' X.M'14" ./4 %':%'."*'( ";$%$#("- #"24'# – "Y4".'4B(/$ 7$4) ) =1$,)%('8 1"4)#'%("1*B.

D%"$2* #48 "0),12">" 345.'" " 2';$1*='A ;$4"=$2'." @ ($, 5*=$%'$*18 9%),'* ";$4"=$;$12">" C'2*"%'": 2"%$((/$ 9%".4$,/ =$2' "('#" )12'*B ($ =($ ;$4"=$2', ' = ($, 1',",". X*' )#$8 ./4' 9":'),1*="='(' 5 9%$:)#$(*' 345.' – E.D$;;$).

«J/ #"4&(/ ./4) 1%";(" ('-*) 19"1". 9%".)*B .%$GB = 15?$1*=5<?$- 91)A"4">);$12"- 95*'()7$ ) ($%':.$%)A$, 9%$"#"4$*B .'%B$%/ 1',"#"="4B1*=',

1',"5=$%$(("1*) )4) C'*'4):,', :' 2"*"%/,) 4<#) .$11":('*$4B(" 52%/='<*18 "* ($9%)8*("- )4) ($9"(8*("- ), #$-1*=)*$4B("1*), ) :'1*'=)*B )A 514/G'*B ('G 9%):/=. @ *" &$ =%$,8 ,/ 9"2' ($ ,">4) 9%$#4"&)*B ()2'2)A 2"(2%$*(/A )

./1*%/A %$G$()-, 2"*"%/$ =/=$4) ./ 4<#$- ): (/($G()A :'*%5#($()-; ."4$$ *">", (', 9%$#1*"84" $?$ ,(">"$ 9%"81()*B = ('G)A 1".1*=$((/A ,/148A ) )#$8A, 2"*"%/$ ) 1',), (', 2':'4)1B ($ =9"4($ 9"14$#"='*$4B(/,), 4">);(/,) ) 5.$#)*$4B(/,). +'2 ;*" ('G$ ="::='()$ #"4&(" ./4", 9%$$ =1$>",

1"#$%&'*B ($2)$ #"1*'*";(" 5.$#)*$4B(/$ )1A"#(/$ ,/14), 19"1".(/$ (';'*B *5 7$9(5< %$'27)<, 2"*"%'8, 2'2 ,/ ('#$84)1B, .5#$* %':%'1*'*B18.

@ 1$(*8.%$ 1969 >"#', =" =%$,8 ('G$- =1*%$;) (' 9%$2%'1(", *)%"4B12", 25%"%*$ = E4B9.'A$, (', 9%$#1*'=)4'1B =$1B,' :','(;)='8 =":,"&("1*B 9%"#=)(5*B18 2 9"1*'=4$(("- 7$4). O#$1B, = E4B9.'A$, (';)('8 1 1945 >"#' E=1*%)-12)- 2"44$#& 51*%')='4 *%'#)7)"((/$ 4$*()$ =1*%$;), >#$ ($12"4B2" 1"*$( 9%)>4'G$((/A ".15'4) 1="- 9%".4$,/ - >4'=(/, ".%':", ,"4"#$&B ): :'9'#("$=%"9$-12)A 1*%'(, A"*8 ./='4) :#$1B ) 9%$#1*'=)*$4) 1 @"1*"2', ) ',$%)2'(7/. (D%">%',,' =1*%$;) =24<;'4' = 1$.8 :('2",1*=" 1 1"=%$,$(("-

2

,5:/2"-, 254B*5%"- ) )12511*=", %':(/A 1*%'(.) @ *5 "1$(B >4'=('8 *$,' ./4': «Z5#5?$$ - 9%$#=)#$()$, ):5;$()$, 94'()%"='()$». J/ %$G)4) "%>'():"='*B 19$7)'4B("$ :'1$#'()$, 1=8:'(("$ 1 52':'(("- ".?$- *$,'*)2"- ) 9"1=8?$(("$ ".15$()< 1"=,$1*("- "*=$*1*=$(("1*) %':=)*/A 1*%'( :' %$G$()$ 9%".4$,

.5#5?$>" =1$>" ,)%'.»

M'14" 9"4'>'$*, ;*" %':=)*)$ 1""*=$*1*=5<?)A 91)A"4">);$12)A 2';$1*= 4<#$- ,"&$* 9%)=$1*) 2 2"%$(("- 9$%$1*%"-2$ ,'*$%)'4B(/A 514"=)- 15?$1*="='()8 7)=)4):'7)). "X*" ;$4"=$;$12'8 %$="4<7)8, (':='(('8 = 9%"$2*$ %$="4<7)$- ,)%"="- 1"4)#'%("1*), ."4$$ ('1*"8*$4B(', ;$, ;*"-4)." )("$...

"(' =$#$* ;$4"=$;$1*=" 2 &):($19"1".(",5 .5#5?$,5", – :'8=484 M'14". 0$;B )#$* " ($2"- ,$&24'11"="- 1"4)#'%("1*), 82"./ 9"4$:("- #48 1":#'()8 #=)&$()8 9%) 5;'1*)) %$4)>)":(/A ) 9"4)*);$12)A *$;$()- :' %':=)*)$ ($2)A ("=/A 91)A"4">);$12)A 2';$1*= ;$4"=$2'.

@)#),", "**5#' – ): 9%"$2*' M'14" "#5$* =$*$%", 2">#' *" ) #$4" 9"8=48<*18 ("=/$ " >5,'()1*);$12)$ " ) " ,)%"4<.)=/$ " #=)&$()8 ) "%>'():'7)) . @ 1"=%$,$(("- %$'4B("1*) 6*" : " .'A') " – 1)(*$*);$12'8 =1$%$4)>)":('8 2"(7$97)8, 2%)G('):, ',$%)2'(12">" ".%':7', #)'($*)2',

#=)&$()$ "(B< 6-#&" ) 9%. @1$ C)('(1"=/$, "%>'():'7)"((/$ ) )#$"4">);$12)$

"()*";2)" =$#5* = !KE, ;*" 1"=1$, ($ 5#)=)*$4B(".

!4$#5<?)- #"24'# X.M'14" =/G$4 9"# (':='()$, "N$4) ;$4"=$;$1*='" = 1":#'()) 2"*"%">" =9$%=/$ 5;'1*="='4) 5;$(/$ ): 1"7)'4)1*);$12)A 1*%'(.

E=*"%/ ".%'?'<*18 2 9%".4$,', ".$19$;$()8 .$:"9'1("1*) ,

9%"#"="4B1*=$(("- 9%">%',,$ , 1('.&$()8 6($%>)$- ) %$15%1',) ,

1*),54)%"='()8 %':=)*)8, 9%$"#"4$()$ 15?$1*=5<?$>" = ,)%$ %'1A"$()8 7$4$- (!), 9%$98*1*=5<?)A 2"(1"4)#'7)) =1$A 4<#$-. @ 7$4", *"( #"24'#' 1"A%'()418 "* 9%$#/#5?$>". D1)A"4">):, ) 15.P$2*)=):, M'14" =/%':)418 =

3

17$('%)) "4)#$%1*=' ('52) ) %$4)>))". L,$((" 6*) #=' =$2*"%' ;$4"=$;$12"-

#$8*$4B("1*), 9" $>" ,($()<, 1,">5* =/=$1*) ,)% (' "95*B )1*)((/-".

2.4. F*#%1)+6+&' & 7%$206-*#&.* 8 %6G6+&& /0$2*04+5B 7%$206- 8 )$.0*)*B ,&-".$-1 .0121

@1$ ,"#$4) >4".'4B(">" 62"(",);$12">" %':=)*)8, %'11,"*%$((/$ = #'(("- 1*'*B$ (%'=(" 2'2 ) 9"14$#5<?)$: E.D$;;$) "W$4"=$;$12)$ 2';$1*='", 1977; S&. Z"*2)(, J. X4B,'(#*%', J. J'4)*7' "H$* 9%$#$4"= ".5;'$,"1*)", 1979; +. #$ J"(.%)'4B "X($%>)8: ".%'*(/- 1;$*", 1979 ) #%.) ,"&(" ) (5&(" "7$()='*B, 2'2 ,)(),5,, = #=5A 94"12"1*8A. 11

1. !5>5." 62"(",);$12)- '19$2*. @1$ 9%"$2*/-#"24'#/ '2*5'4B(/. X*"

.$119"%(". E2*5'4B(/ ./4) = 70-$, *$, ."4$$ '2*5'4B(/ 1*'4) 1$-;'1, 2">#' ,/ ,"&$, ('.4<#'*B )A ="94"?$()$. H$1,"*%8 (' 1=") 94<1/ ) ,)(51/, =1$ ,"#$4), *'2 )4) )(';$. 9%$*="%8<*18 = %$'4B("1*B ()4) &$ :'#'<* $$?).

X2"(",)2', 2'2 "5,$()$ =$1*) A":8-1*=" = 1="$, #",$-62"1$", = 1',",

#$4$, 9$%$1*'4' ./*B *'2"="-. T(' 1*'4' ",)%"="-" ) ".4'1*B $$ 9%$*="%$()8

(62"1) – 6*" =$1B :$,("- G'%. D"6*",5, =1$, #'&$ ):"4)%"='((/$ >"15#'%1*='

(*)9' !$=$%("- 3"%$)) ($ ,">5* ($ 5;)*/='*B 9%"7$11"=, 9%")1A"#8?)A = 62"(",)2$ #%5>)A 1*%'( , "1".$((" 1*%'( =/1"2"%':=)*/A . I1*$1*=$((" ,

62"(",);$12)- '19$2* #"="4B(" ".G)%$(, "( =24<;'$* = 1$.8 5;$* %$15%1"=:

,)($%'4B(/A (1/%B$=/A), 6($%>$*);$12)A, *%5#"=/A (;$4"=$2 = 2"(*$21*$ 62"(",);$12"- %$'4B("1*) #'=(" 5&$ 1*'4 9%)#'*2", 62"(",)2)) ; 5;$*

11	?. B&%6, E U%)W$#.. I#.")/ 6(-8)(N%)/ .#"-(M1&/. >-2()$ 4&5+2-6- 2(78). A., 1991. . c.145